Seeing Poe’s Struggle with Alcoholism

In: English and Literature

Submitted By andalou
Words 4958
Pages 20
Seeing Poe’s Struggle with Alcoholism through his Stories “The Cask of Amontillado” and “The Black Cat”
Jen Andalou

Edgar Allen Poe’s stories “The Black Cat” and “The Cask of Amontillado” are among his most popular. Both of these stories can be read on several different levels causing everyone who reads them to come up with a totally different interpretations, yet none of the interpretations I have read seem satisfying. The two stories at first seem simple enough, with “The Black Cat” reading as a darker version of “The Telltale Heart”, this time with the conscience given a physical form, and “The Cask of Amontillado” as a chilling tale of revenge exacted told as a deathbed confession. Yet these simple interpretations leave too many questions. Many reviewers unfairly single Poe’s works out as coming directly from his subconscious, ignoring not only how carefully Poe chose his words and phrases but also the sources that inspired the stories (E A Poe Society,
“Autobiography”). That being said, I think Poe did deliberately use his stories as a kind of self-therapy thus revealing at least a little about himself. A large constant in Poe’s life was his fight with alcohol, which made itself known in his writing in many ways.
The main theme of Edgar Allen Poe’s stories “The Black Cat” and “The Cask of
Amontillado” centers on the narrators’ attempts to wall off, or suppress, his alcoholism, with the narrator succeeding over alcoholism in “The Cask of Amontillado” while the narrator of “The Black Cat” succumbs to alcohol and is destroyed. As a last step I will show that the reason these two stories came to such different conclusions is mirrored in
Poe’s attempts to suppress his own alcoholism during the periods of time in which each of these stories was written.

The use of alcohol is very prominent in Poe’s story “The Black Cat” which can be read…...

Similar Documents

Poe's Dark Appeal

...Poe’s Dark Appeal There are few writers as adept at invoking feelings and images of darkness, dread, and depression in a reader as successfully as Edgar Allan Poe. Born in Boston in 1809 to impoverished actors David and Elizabeth Poe (Allen), Edgar’s entire existence seems to have been destined for struggle and loss. He was orphaned by age three, losing his mother to tuberculosis and his father by desertion (Allen). He was taken in by the Allan family, but during Edgar’s year-long stint at West Point in 1830—and subsequent expulsion—his relationship with his foster father suffered irreparable damage (“Biography”). His life soon became a mélange of depression, alcoholism, unemployment, and financial hardship (“Biography”). He died in 1949 while on a trip to Baltimore, under mysterious circumstances: theories of “congestion of the brain,” alcoholism, rabies, epilepsy, and carbon monoxide poisoning continue to swarm today (“Biography”). Having lived a life of constant struggle and turmoil, it is not surprising that his works are imbued with brooding and despondency, and that the common themes in his writings revolve around derangement and death. His short story “The Tell-Tale Heart” provides a perfect example of his fixation with madness, murder, and melancholy. It is this very fascination with all things grotesque, combined with his uncanny ability to weave multiple literary elements together to create a bizarre tapestry that appeals to readers, and what makes Edgar Allan......

Words: 1368 - Pages: 6

Alcoholism awareness of the relationship between experience and the wider society, a person must be able to pull away from situation and think from an alternative point of view (Crossman, 2009). People have problems within themselves but become an alcoholic which does not solve the problems. Alcohol has the potential to devastate your life. Some would say they do not know which is worse being able to live with one or being an alcoholic. When you living with an alcoholic it take a toll on the people around you and more than 40 percent of Americans have been exposed to alcoholism in their family. There seem to be an increased risk of becoming alcoholics themselves. Children of alcoholics are certain to be abused, depression, and behavioral problems. Why do people drink and not become addicted while become alcoholics, the reason has to do with genetic, physiological, psychological and social factors. The development of alcoholism is an important factor of genes, which means if you had live with someone who drinks more than likely, you become a drinker and it due to environmental factors. Alcohol can affect the chemicals in the brain. The body starts to crave it to get feelings or to avoid feelings. Peer pressure and environment have a major effect on a person to become an alcoholic. There are several signs that someone may be an alcoholic which include: Drinking to forget your problems, alone often, and lying about the drinking habits. Also, it is losing interest in food, feeling......

Words: 585 - Pages: 3


...Alcoholism: Choice or Disease Mitzy Morgan Drug Abuse Soc2133 J.Kirk September 28,2011 Imagine yourself being 11 years old. You and your next-door neighbor just finished eating dinner, and now playing cards in front of the television. A few hours pass and your mother tells you that its bedtime. After being asleep for a couple of hours, you hear your father come inside your house. This was not unusual; he always comes home late at night. You hear your parents yell at each other and then you hear an awful sound. Did your father just hit your mother only because his dinner was cold, and he was late? You ask yourself why, why is he like this? He is like this because he is an alcoholic and cannot control his temper when he has been drinking. The next day you promise your mom and yourself that when you grow up you were never going to become an alcoholic. You see what your father’s alcoholism has done to your family and yourself and would never want that to happen to your family when you become an adult. Twenty years later, you too become an alcoholic. Children of alcoholics are four times more likely to grow up to be an alcoholic than any other children, according to the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. One in five adult Americans lived with an alcoholic while growing up. (AACAP) Studies have shown that even twins separated at birth and living in two very different environments......

Words: 1295 - Pages: 6


...under any conditions whatever," states Bill Wilson the co-founder of Alcoholics Anonymous. AA, also known as Alcoholics Anonymous, is a recovery program to help addicts cure their addiction. The addict is given a sponsor within the first 30 days of your recovery and he or she guides through the twelve steps of Alcoholics Anonymous. These twelve steps help the addict accept they have a problem, identify what exactly needs to be improved and changed, analyze the situation, learn from their progress and past mistakes, and help yourself and others. This racially mixed, self-supporting, and nonprofessional recovery program is the only way to cure addiction and reach the full potential of sobriety. In the 1930’s, it was common to consider alcoholism as a moral failure. Doctors at the time treated the situation like it was terminal. People without financial capability were able to find help through the Salvation Army or religious groups, while those who could afford it were put into a long term treatment in hospitals. In 1931 a Christian society named The Oxford Group practiced the five C’s: confidence, confession, conviction, conversion, and continuance. Bill Wilson, a struggling addict, needed support for his addiction and learned the beliefs of the Christian group. In 1935 he established what is now known today as Alcoholics Anonymous and The Oxford Group’s guidance formed the foundation of the twelve step program. Wilson wrote, “The early AA got its ideas of......

Words: 1968 - Pages: 8


...Alcoholism is drinking alcoholic beverages at a level that interferes with physical health, mental health, and social, family, or job responsibilities. Alternative Names Alcohol dependence; Alcohol abuse Causes Alcoholism is a type of drug addiction. There is both physical and mental dependence on alcohol. Alcoholism is divided into 2 categories: dependence and abuse. People who are dependent on alcohol spend a great deal of time drinking alcohol, and getting it. Physical dependence involves: • A need for increasing amounts of alcohol to get drunk or achieve the desired effect (tolerance) • Alcohol-related illnesses • Memory lapses (blackouts) after drinking episodes • Withdrawal symptoms when alcohol use is stopped The most severe drinking behavior includes long drinking binges that lead to mental or physical problems. Some people are able to gain control over their dependence in earlier phases before they totally lose control. But no one knows which heavy drinkers will be able to regain control and which will not. There is no known common cause of alcoholism. However, several factors may play a role in its development. A person who has an alcoholic parent is more likely to become an alcoholic than a person without alcoholism in the immediate family. Research suggests that certain genes may increase the risk of alcoholism, but which genes or how they work is not known. Psychological factors may include: • A need for anxiety relief • Conflict in relationships ...

Words: 1699 - Pages: 7


...their problems. Not only does the use of alcohol create serious health disorders for those who drink heavily during their lifetime, but also causes serious health disorders in children whose mothers drank while pregnant. Individuals who drink alcohol are often responsible for injuring other innocent people. Each year in the United States, nearly 85,000 people die from alcohol-related causes, making it the third leading preventable cause of death in our country. (NIAAA) Many automobile accidents involve drunk drivers. People who drink endanger themselves and everyone around them. In addition, business and industry suffer financial loss because their employees drink. What might begin as casual drinking can become heavy drinking and alcoholism. Because the abuse of alcohol has a negative effect on men, women, and children, that same abuse on alcohol is a threat in our society. Although society cannot force people to stop abusing alcohol, society does try to provide rehabilitation for heavy drinkers and alcoholics. People who watch television commercials and read magazine advertisements perhaps think that the use of alcohol can be a positive factor in their life. But according to the author of Alcohol: The Delightful Poison, “alcohol is classified as a drug and is recognized as a depressant that acts as an anesthetic on the central nervous system, and is a consciousness changing drug.” (Fleming p.122)  Nearly 18 million adults in the U.S. are dependent on alcohol or......

Words: 2160 - Pages: 9


...Alcoholism in Adult Magoha Mayagila Research Paper, Psych 2301 Alcohol Use Disorder (AUD) is a non-curable mental disorder that’s affects millions of people worldwide. According to national institute on alcohol and alcoholism, 1 in 12 adults in U.S is suffering from AUD. If not diagnosed early, AUD can effects a person life psychologically, socially and economically. Despite affecting the general population, studies have shown men are two to three times more likely to develop AUD than women due to generic differences (Mettmann D 2014). The androgen receptor (AR) gene, located on X chromosome contains a common polymorphism involving cytosine-adenine-guanine (CAG) repeats, which impacts disease and could contribute the unequal sex ratio in alcoholism (Mettman D 2014). Even though men are more susceptible to AUD, the effects of AUD on women health is enormous compared to men. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) is a psychological tool that have been used to collect mental disorder statistics since 1840. By 1952 American Psychiatric Association developed DMS-I to diagnose mental disorders. Prior to 2013, DMS-IV was the tool of choice for clinical diagnosis for alcoholism. DMS-IV categorized alcoholism into two distinct disorders, alcohol abuse and alcohol dependency; and two distinct criteria, abuse and dependency based on 11 symptoms. Alcohol abuse is defined as a behavior at which a person drinking pattern leads to undesirable acts and......

Words: 1052 - Pages: 5


...person’s drug use is a result of some aspects of some or all the other models * Treatment and recovery require addressing the body, mind, social, nutrition, employment, family issues, psychological issues. On a broad inference, addiction is generally concerned with alcoholism so therefore we shall talk extensively on alcoholism. ALCOHOLISM Alcoholism is a broad term for problems with alcohol, and is generally used to mean compulsive and uncontrolled consumption of alcoholic beverages, usually to the detriment of the drinker's health, personal relationships, and social standing. It is medically considered a disease, specifically an addictive illness. In psychiatry several other terms have been used, specifically "alcohol abuse", "alcohol dependence," and "alcohol use disorder" which have slightly different definitions. Alcohol misuse has the potential to damage almost every organ in the body, including the brain. The cumulative toxic effects of chronic alcohol abuse can cause both medical and psychiatric problems. The American Medical Association considers alcoholism as a disease and supports a classification that includes both physical and mental components. The biological mechanisms that cause alcoholism are not well understood. Social environment, stress, mental health, family history, age, ethnic group, and gender all influence the risk for the condition. Significant alcohol intake produces changes in the brain's structure and chemistry, though some alterations......

Words: 3596 - Pages: 15


...Alcoholism In today’s society, alcoholism is quickly becoming a menace. It is a disease that is affecting people of all ages, but has been observed to be rampant in the younger generation. Continued abuse of alcohol can have adverse effects on one’s physical, mental, emotional and spiritual health as well as other undesirable effects to the community. One risks dangers such as irreversible damage to crucial organs and body systems, for example, one risks liver and heart failure in addition to a compromised brain, nervous system, and stomach. Alcoholism also has severe consequences to one's social life. It can lead to cases of domestic violence, loss of employment, marital conflicts, and isolation from family and friends. In order to control alcohol abuse, we have to be able to recognize the symptoms of alcoholism. By knowing them, we can quickly identify an alcoholic and take the necessary steps forward. Physical symptoms are the most obvious. They include incoherent speech, poor balance, delayed reflexes, blackouts or loss of consciousness, persistent stomach pains, nausea and vomiting, and redness of the face during and after periods of heavy consumption (Littrell, 2014). Increased abuse of alcohol results to more serious medical symptoms, which include expression of anger and other emotions especially in inappropriate places, participating in risky activities that have serious health financial and legal consequences, neglecting family and professional obligations,......

Words: 1174 - Pages: 5

Critical Essay: Elements of Literature in Poe’s “Cask of Amontillado"

...Critical Essay: Elements of Literature in Poe’s “Cask of Amontillado” Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Cask of Amontillado” Is a well written shorty story filled with many significant literary elements. Firstly we will write about the plot, the overall summary of the story, and the main themes, the central ideas of this tale. The plot of "The Cask of Amontillado" is a great account of vengeance. The assassin promises “revenge” upon Fortunato for an “insult.” The main theme revolves around the assassin plans to pursue vengeance in support of his family motto: "Nemo me impune lacessit. This means “no one cuts (attacks) me with impunity.” On the coat of arms of his family, which bears this motto, looks "a huge human foot d'or, in a field of azure; the foot crushes a serpent rampant whose fangs are embedded in the heel.” Thus reflects the theme of vengeance because the assassin’s plan of revenge on Fortunato for an insult. Secondly we have characterization, the personalities of the characters of the characters produced. The true focus lies upon the assassin, the wicked Montresor. Montresor is an evil man who is happy at his chance to murder. The costume that Fortunato donned on the night of his murder was that of a jester, while......

Words: 758 - Pages: 4


...Kendra Alcoholism Overview: Alcoholism is a medically diagnosed disease which manifests itself in the frequent use of alcohol, despite the negative consequences it has on a person’s life. Genetic predisposition, environment, and mental health are the leading risk factors for developing alcoholism. Alcohol problems are severe and involve substantial consumption of alcohol, which results in multiple physical and psychosocial problems. Symptoms: Signs and symptoms of alcoholism include significant hangovers, which increase in time needed to recover, increased amount of alcohol consumed because of increased tolerance, lowered self ambition, irreversible damage to critical organs such as the liver, nervous system, heart, stomach, and brain. Common medical side effects include high blood pressure, sexual problems, cancer, osteoporosis, and depression. Treatment: There is no cure for alcoholism but treatment can help. Treatment can only begin once the addict accepts the problem exists, is motivated to change and agrees to stop drinking. The most common treatment is done in 3 stages; Detoxification, rehabilitation, and maintained of sobriety. Detoxification is needed immediately after discounting alcohol. This should be done at a hospital because detox can result in withdrawal seizures, hallucinations, delirium tremens, and in some cases death. Rehabilitation involves counseling and medication to give the alcoholic the skills need to maintain sobriety. Therapy might include......

Words: 254 - Pages: 2


...Alcoholism Alcoholism refers to a chronic disease where your body becomes dependent on alcohol. Being an alcoholic is not limited to gender, race, or age. At any time while drinking people can form a dependence to alcohol. To fully understand the meaning of being an alcoholic, what it does to the body, and the recovery processes that follow, it is important to remember that alcoholism is an addiction and can affect anyone. The DSM IV defines alcoholism as a maladaptive pattern of alcohol use, leading to clinically significant impairment or distress, as manifested by three or more of the seven criteria, occurring at any time in the same 12-month period. Some of the major criteria are; building a tolerance to alcohol, withdrawal symptoms arise after not drinking, and it take more and more alcohol to feel the effects over time (DSM IV 1994). Now these are just the top three criteria but if a person has three out of the seven then they are considered an alcoholic even if they themselves do not want to accept that title. Some people think that it is very shameful to have a title of addict because of the negative stigma American society puts on that word. Men might feel emasculated, women might feel weak, and teens fighting this illness might be overwhelmed and confused because their peers put so much pride on being able to drink more than each other. So many phrases are becoming popular among teenagers that promote excess drinking under 21. Some of these phrases include; being...

Words: 888 - Pages: 4


...Madison Jones PSYC 2301 Alcoholism in the U.K., U.S.A., & Canada I chose these three countries because one of them has a drinking age of 18, one has a drinking age of 19, and the other one has a drinking age that is 21. I thought it would be interesting to compare these three countries in regards to how the legal drinking age corresponds to its alcoholism rates. To begin, the average population for each country is as follows: U.K.64.4 million, U.S.-323.4 million, and Canada-35.4 million (Graph A). Compared to the UK and Canada, the US has 223.6 million more people than the other two countries combined. As far as what percentage of each individual’s population that qualifies as alcoholic, about 14% of the UK drinks more than the legal limit regularly, about 4% of the US has an issue with the drug, and about 9% of the population of Canada is considered to be alcoholic (Graph B). The reason why the UK’s percentage is so high might be due to its drinking age. Since alcohol is more readily available to the youth of the United Kingdom, it would make sense that the rate of alcoholism would be much higher than in countries like the United States. This is also a problem in Canada, where alcohol is considered to be “the most abused drug in Canada” (1). This is most likely due to the drinking age as well. While the UK and Canada sit about five percent, the US has a surprisingly low score of 4%. One would think that the United States would have had a higher percentage......

Words: 448 - Pages: 2


...The Deadly Affect Alcoholism had a major affect on the life of the famous director/comedian Sherman Alexie. He grew up in a family that was addicted to alcohol, so he has always had a good understanding of how alcohol can affect a person and others around them. He put this knowledge into film in the 1990’s movie Smoke Signals. Statistically 58% of deaths are alcohol related. Alcohol has an affect on the lives of everyone. When it is consumed, people tend to do a lot of things they would never think of doing. It plays a major role on our life today. When under the influence the decisions made by alcoholics are sometimes fatal to not only themselves but others around them. In the movie Smoke Signals alcoholism is portrayed through a Native American Indian reservation. The main character Victor Joseph deals with alcoholism at its worst with an abusive alcoholic father. This movie shows how a family battles through alcoholism and how it affects them afterwards. In the 1998 film Smoke Signals, Victor grew up on an Indian reservation with his family. Arnold, Victor’s father, was an alcoholic who accidentally lit his friend’s house on fire. The parents of the house were killed, but Arnold managed to save their son Thomas. After he burnt down their house Arnold was never the same. He began to become more of an alcoholic due to his depression. One night Arnold and his wife decided to throw a party. Victor came outside while they were drinking and his dad came up to him and......

Words: 780 - Pages: 4


...Alcoholism Name: Institution: Alcoholism This refers to the excessive consumption of alcohol. This condition is considered a disease in the medical field. A person suffering from this condition is referred to as an alcoholic. Alcoholics have an incontrollable urge to keep on drinking despite the obvious physical, social and mental problems associated with alcoholism. Physical risk factors associated with alcoholism include damage to the nervous system, epilepsy, pancreatitis, dementia and an increased risk of liver and cardiovascular diseases (Galanter, 2005). Alcoholism is considered the third most common mental problem with the most major risk factor being depression. This is as a result of the alcoholic having low self esteem and feeling out of place thus becoming antisocial. Alcoholics become very irritable when confronted about their drinking problem. This usually leads to them alienating themselves as they feel judged and misunderstood which sometimes leads to the alcoholic becoming suicidal (Galanter, 2005). Medical practitioners have carried out research to determine the causes of alcoholism with some speculating that the condition is hereditary. Studies show that people with a history of being either physically or sexually abused as children have a higher likelihood of developing alcoholism as they already feel out of place. Furthermore, children who engage in alcohol intake before the age of 15years are more likely...

Words: 608 - Pages: 3