Rationality, Norms and Identity in Ir

In: Social Issues

Submitted By Samolyakkatya
Words 8767
Pages 36
Original Article

Rationality, norms and identity in international relations Ji Young Choi
Department of Politics & Government, Ohio Wesleyan University, Elliott Hall 204, Delaware,
OH 43015, USA.
E-mail: jychoi@owu.edu

Abstract This article examines major debates between rationalism and constructivism.
It presents that there are politically significant motives of social actions, including norms and identity, which cannot be completely subsumed by the concept of instrumental rationality. These ideational or social-psychological motivations are governed primarily by thymos or affect (the moral or emotional part of the human personality) and/or valueoriented rationality. We need more flexible assumptions about main actors and their motives than those of rationalism to explain appropriately the politics of anger, loyalty and a sense of justice at international levels. However, constructivism’s emphasis on ideational motivations cannot totally replace rationalism in explaining international political life. Constructivism maintains that identity or norms are causally prior to actors’ interests. Yet when there is conflict between pursuit of interests and maintenance of identity or norms, actors’ strong and well-defined self-interests can overrule their contested or unstable identity or norms. In short, causal arrows can flow in either direction between identity or norms and interests. This implies that rationalism and constructivism are complementary rather than competitive in explaining international political life.
International Politics (2015) 52, 110–127. doi:10.1057/ip.2014.41
Keywords: rationalism; constructivism; rationality; norms; identity; international relations theory

Since the 1990s, one of the major debates in International Relations (IR) scholarship has been between rationalism and constructivism (Katzenstein et al,…...

Similar Documents

Utility and Rationality

...International automobile giants like Toyota, Ford, Chevrolet, Mercedes, Suzuki and Hyundai have carved a niche for themselves in the Indian market. The plausible success factor of these foreign players in the Indian four-wheeler market is the widespread research of the consumer behaviour. All aspects of the behaviour pattern of the Indian consumer across all socio-economic strata, regions and towns are extensively studied. These include lifestyle, personal tastes and preferences, receptiveness for an effective product, credit availability, income growth, exposure to media, etc. Utility and Rationality People demand goods because the latter satisfy the wants of the former. A car manufacturer, like any other firm operates in order to create something for the satisfaction of some wants. An automobile company produces car to serve as a safe and comfortable means of commutation. Car has utility for people who desire to have a car. While a person staying near the office place does not show much desire to own a car, one residing away from the work place has much more desire to possess one. The 2008 four-wheeler Total Satisfaction Survey by TNS Automotive, a comprehensive automotive study in India covers over 45 models with evaluation of consumer behaviour in key areas of sales satisfaction, product quality, vehicle performance and design, after-sales service, brand image and cost of ownership. The Total Consumer Satisfaction (TCS) index provides a measure of satisfaction the......

Words: 290 - Pages: 2


...Identity 1: Professional Identity Professional is defined by Merriam-Webster's dictionary as "characterized by or conforming to the technical or ethical standards of one's profession." One of the identities I use almost every day is “professional”. As a Technology and Financial Support Manager it is imperative that I conduct myself as a professional. In many situations at work, I find myself holding back from a particular comment, or a joke I would normally make without hesitation in a different environment. At Bates College where I work there are many ethical standards that must be followed. The college is rich in diversity and has many programs in place to support all different religions, cultures and sexual preferences. It is critical to my position that I represent my department and my fellow managers in a professional manner. Identity 2: Parent Parent is defined by Merriam-Webster’s dictionary as “one that begets or brings forth offspring.” Yahoo asked in a survey “define a parent” Top Answer: A parent should always be there for you, teach you, be a mentor, a friend when needed, help you with decisions and be stern when needed. A parent has many responsibilities it’s really hard to put everything down but they should always be a shoulder to cry on and someone to laugh with yet always show you right from wrong. Unfortunately there are several parents; fathers and mothers who fit Webster’s description. This is all they are/do. My second identity, a very......

Words: 479 - Pages: 2

Bounded Rationality

...Published in: Swiss Journal of Economics and Statistics, 133 (2/2), 1997, 201–218. © 1997 Peter Lang, 0303-9692. Bounded Rationality: Models of Fast and Frugal Inference Gerd Gigerenzer1 Max Planck Institute for Psychological Research, Munich, Germany Humans and other animals need to make inferences about their environment under constraints of limited time, knowledge, and computational capacities. However, most theories of inductive inferences model the human mind as a supercomputer like a Laplacean demon, equipped with unlimited time, knowledge, and computational capacities. In this article I review models of fast and frugal inference, that is, satisficing strategies whose task is to infer unknown states of the world (without relying on computationaly expensive procedures such as multiple regression). Fast and frugal inference is a form of bounded rationality (Simon, 1982). I begin by explaining what bounded rationality in human inference is not. 1. Bounded Rationality is Not Irrationality In his chapter in John Kagel and Alvin Roth’s Handbook of Experimental Economics (1995), Colin Camerer explains that “most research on individual decision making has taken normative theories of judgment and choice (typically probability rules and utility theories) as null hypotheses about behavior,” and has labeled systematic deviations from these norms “cognitive illusions” (p. 588). Camerer continues, “The most fruitful, popular alternative theories spring from the idea that......

Words: 7402 - Pages: 30


...Austin West English 101 Mr. Tessaro 11 November 2012 Identiwho? Identity. It defines who we are. But what are we? And what defines identity? Are we measured solely by our given names? Or is there a much deeper, more mystical sense of ourselves imposed by the word? We all have a name bestowed upon us at birth. Some have a first and last name, while others have three or more. Do names give us power? Throughout history many noble families, including bloodlines that ran through monarchies and even that of Indian tribes, had inherited leadership. Whenever the current leader was no longer able to rule, the position was handed down to his oldest living successor. Names were obviously of great importance then. However, there were times in history where only one name was given or deemed necessary. Perhaps names are not a badge of power, but rather a personal identifier to simply set one apart from rest. Occupation is often one of the first things to come up in a conversation. Following name exchanges, people generally want to know what the other person does for a living. Why is that of importance? It must have some bearing on how people are viewed. Oftentimes, lower-waged occupations are looked down upon (BNZ). This is because the person is considered “not good enough” to work as anything better. Where as a janitor might be seen as dirty, lowly, uneducated trash; a doctor would be seen as highly intelligent, healthy, and sophisticated. People would want...

Words: 1563 - Pages: 7

Ir Theories

...ever since. The critics’ reaction to this liberal internationalism dominated the discipline’s early years. Carr (1939/1945/1946: Chapter 1), who was one of the more scathing of them, maintained that ‘utopians’ were guilty of ‘naivety’ and ‘exuberance’. Visionary zeal stood in the way of dispassionate analysis. The realist critique of liberal internationalism launched by Carr immediately before the Second World War, and continued by various scholars including Morgenthau in the United States in the 1940s and 1950s led to the so-called first ‘great debate’. Whether this debate actually occurred has been contested by recent scholars (Wilson 1998); however the myth of a great debate between the realists and the idealists gave the discipline its identity in the post-Second World War years. Interestingly Carr (1939/1945/1946), who criticised the utopians for Scott Burchill and Andrew Linklater 9 their ‘naivety’ also turned his guns on the realists, accusing them of ‘sterility’ and ‘complacency’. Theories acquire dominance in any discipline for different reasons, such as the extent to which they prevail in debates with their adversaries (sometimes more imagined than real). They can also be the beneficiary of widespread beliefs that they are right for the times or more relevant to the dominant events of the day than are other perspectives. The ‘twenty years’ crisis’ culminating in the Second World War and followed by the Cold War era led in any case to the dominance of......

Words: 132890 - Pages: 532


...However, as much of a role as I think it plays in my identity, it is not singularly consumed by filmmaking. It’s consumed by many ingredients. Identity is compiled of endless traits, qualities, concepts, and morals that describe who you truly are as an individual and completely set you apart from the social norm. “My identity is what prevents me from being identical to anybody else” (Reader, pg. 40). A basic concept this is, but with a very specific message. Amin Maalouf, writer of In the Name of Identity, describes his identity as being a way to set himself apart. Maalouf writes heavily on religion and heritage. This relates to the concept of vertical and horizontal heritage. Your vertical heritage is your religious beliefs and morals passed down from your parents. On the opposite, your horizontal heritage is linked by your influences from your environment―the area in which you were raised and grew up in. Maalouf identifies himself as both Lebanese and French. One of Maalouf’s main focus is to praise the human ability to identify oneself in many ways. “...through each one of my affiliations, taken separately, I possess a certain kinship with a large number of my fellow human beings; but because of all these allegiances, taken together, I possess my own identity, completely different from any other” (Reader, pg. 44). This is what Maalouf wants to stress the most; because of his various backgrounds and life elements, his identity has been outlined specific to him and cannot......

Words: 1827 - Pages: 8


...highlights some of the problems of legal rational authority and the solutions that can make it more flexible in communication and decision making Legal rational authority according to Webber was the most rational and most stable of authority. Formal rules and regulations legitimize this authority. People obey orders of the ruler not because they are loyal but because rules and laws stipulate so and must be obeyed Legal rational authority also known as the bureaucratic authority is the form of leadership in which the authority of an organization or ruling regime is largely tied to legal laws. Legitimacy is seen as coming from legal order, meaning the authority follows and obeys the laws that have been enacted and enforced by government. Rationality means the basis by which sound decisions are made by proper reasoning instead of acting on intuition or influence Legal rational authority is the best type of authority reason being unlike these other types of authority, legal rational authority is management based on a formal structure with set rules and regulations which makes it unbiased and professional. As much as it has its flaws, it is the most rational authority because management of an organization is not based on personal relations where employees working in an organization are loyal to a specific individual rather than an organization, if this where the case work would not be done as personal issues would be factored into work and this would bring about inefficiency. In......

Words: 1337 - Pages: 6

Bounded Rationality

...employees would keep on taking short breaks in every hour or two from their production time which leads to decrease in the overall output at the end of the day. The “entry In-Out” system helped the administration to check and verify the employees production hours, whether it met the requirements or not, and also helped in keeping a concurrent data for the future reference, keeping in mind that this would lead to increase in overall production hours of the employees, help in justifying the employee’s appraisal and also increase the overall output for the business. Simon (1957) introduced the term “Bounded Rationality” to express the idea that, as humans, our capacity to process large amounts of data is limited in different ways. It is sometimes described as “Limited rationality” or “subjective rationality”. Hence we make a decision that is “satisficing” to us. While on the contradicting side, according to Gigerenzer & Goldstein (1996) the decision is based on heuristics. A person makes a decision based on their past experience related to their knowledge of other decisions or situations previously. The decision is based on different alternatives. If first alternative is better than the second one, then first alternative is chosen, if both the alternatives are not acceptable then they are compared to a third alternative and so on until the best alternative is found. Which is also conditional to the nature of the decision, the......

Words: 1616 - Pages: 7

Impact of Globalisation on Ir

...Impact of Globalization on IR Impact of Globalization on IR IMPACT OF GLOBALIZATION ON INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS The globalization i.e. the changes in the world economy have substantial effects on the industrial relations thereby providing the opportunity to reiterate the significance of the area in understanding the effect of these changes on the people, organizations and the nature of work. The traditional methods of IR are disturbed in several ways through the increasing international economic interdependence. Initially the IR arrangements are confined to the situations created by the national markets but the globalization has expanded the boundaries of the market place. The amount of information flows with the help of the latest technology is constructing the interconnected enterprise networks around the world, thereby doing away with the current IR arrangements. The primary drivers of change are the MNC’s. They are associations that take part in FDI and own or control profitable resources in more than one nation. The MNC’s, as producers of the universal goods and services have an influence extending beyond the urban places in the countries in which they are located. The individualism is growing in the organizations as many local enterprises in addition to the MNC’s are using the information technology to focus on the demands of the international and domestic markets. The globalization has also clearly shown the difference between the “capital” and the......

Words: 1568 - Pages: 7


...I have undertaken the task of breaking a social norm within the campus grounds. I wanted to see what kind of reactions I could get from a wide variety of people, and since UNL is so diverse with different genders, race, and age, I chose our campus to be my laboratory. I decided that I would try standing in the back of the union by the fountain, and then I would play the guitar and sing out loud as if I were enjoying the nice weather. This would probably seem normal to most people, however, I don’t know how to play the guitar at all and I can’t sing worth anything. I figured the combination of my terrible abilities would make a great formula for gaining attention from other people. I recorded myself doing it so that I could remember what I sang about too. I also thought it would be great to sing about my observations of the people around me. I would sing things such as people looking like animals, or making fun of their clothes, or describing every move they make, or give them a story about their day and how it’s going. One time a tall white guy was walking past me by himself and my first reaction was that he looked like a giraffe, so I went with that. I sang loudly “hey tall guy with the red coat how are you today, when I first saw you, you looked like a giraffe to me, can you tell me giraffe man where I can find some good leaves on a tree, giraffe people are mad all the time that they cant fit through doors, they always hit their head and it gives their head soars, which is......

Words: 367 - Pages: 2


...Going against the Norms Have you ever seen a six foot four inch man get into the driver side of a small vehicle? Or have you checked out a woman with amazing, toned hour glass body and thought to yourself that you look happier than her, so it does not matter what you look like? These situations and thoughts do not come and go often because that is not how we typically think. According to the new 2016 Super Bowl commercials, the two commercials that caught my attention of going against these society norms was the Mini USA campaign defying label’s, as well as the Axe Menswear deodorant during the commercial breaks. Both of these showed in different perspectives of how we could be happy without worrying about our self-image and not worry about what others think. The Mini USA has been promoting the campaign “defying labels” since the 1950’s. When they first created the Classic Mini Coopers; cooperate owner, Sir Alec- designed the cars by flipping the engine sideways and pushing the wheels outwards to create more room in the cockpit. This creative design gave its own unique spontaneity and defied the basic norms of what a car should look like. Majority of the time, anyone who had seen a mini cooper or is discussed amongst population often label the car as “too feminine”. However, there are celebrities who were used into the commercials. The celebrities were Serena Williams, Abby Wambach, Randy Johnson, Tony Hawk, Harvey Keitel, T-Pain. They all had a testimony to share about...

Words: 834 - Pages: 4

Social Norm

...Zoë C.P Gaines English 101 3/26/2016 Following Social Norms Human society is made up of billions of people right? It’s no wonder to me that in order to keep all of the worlds’ people at a level where they can function peacefully, some structures with regard to behaviors and mannerisms are needed. These, structures are better known as social norms. Social norms are the expected and set behaviors that are found within each and every culture around the world. These norms include both social and legal expectations. They constitute the main fabric of a society and its inner workings by setting in place social unwritten rules, also known as common law; which determines how people behave and act towards and around one another. The foremost function of social norms is to institute social structure and permit cohesiveness between members of society. These norms that are set in place are ordinarily accepted as right, or anticipated behavior depending on various circumstances that depend on environment and culture within such society. Once established, members of society who follow and abide by these norms feel more at ease socially while living out their day to day lives. Although, sometimes an individual's personal identity may in some sense be restricted by some social norms, therefore following the common law of the community you live in is generally seen as being good of the society; and therefore following them becomes an advantage to the members of that society. ...

Words: 1361 - Pages: 6

Rationality and Voting

...other demographics in parts of the world actually fight and would even die for the right to vote. One day you could wake up in a country where you can’t. Enough said! Rolling in the autumn leaves or writing sonnets for a lover are “beautiful things” too, but those observations do not constitute arguments for engaging in these activities in a ritualised way together with fellow citizens every two years on the first Tuesday in November. There are, however, more intellectually compelling reasons to encourage the vote that Ms Mangu-Ward brushes off too quickly. First off, your vote could make a big difference, if you live in a swing state. Two of the authors of the Economic Inquiry article cited by Ms Mangu-Ward make the case here for the rationality of voting, despite the slim odds that your vote will determine the election’s outcome. Consider this thought experiment. Suppose that an election looks close so that it seems that the percentage tally will be between a 48–52 split and a 52–48 split between two candidates. If there will be 100 voters, and you are the potential hundred-and-first deciding whether to vote, here is you’re the situation. Assume for simplicity that each percentage split has equal probability. (Little changes if we assign a more complicated probability distribution.) Then there will be either 48, 49, 50, 51, or 52 voters voting for candidate A, each with probability 1/5. If there are 50 voters, then the election is a tie and your vote will be......

Words: 857 - Pages: 4

Bounded Rationality

...BOUNDED RATIONALITY Herbert Simon (1916-2001) is most famous for what is known to economists as the theory of bounded rationality, a theory about economic decision-making that Simon himself preferred to call “satisficing”, a combination of two words: “satisfy” and “suffice”. Contrary to the tenets of classical economics, Simon maintained that individuals do not seek to maximise their benefit from a particular course of action (since they cannot assimilate and digest all the information that would be needed to do such a thing). Not only can they not get access to all the information required, but even if they could, their minds would be unable to process it properly. The human mind necessarily restricts itself. It is, as Simon put it, bounded by “cognitive limits”. Hence people, in many different situations, seek something that is “good enough”, something that is satisfactory. Humans, for example, when in shopping mode, aspire to something that they find acceptable, although that may not necessarily be optimal. They look through things in sequence and when they come across an item that meets their aspiration level they go for it. This real-world behaviour is what Simon called satisficing. He applied the idea to organisations as well as to individuals. Managers do much the same thing as shoppers in a mall. “Whereas economic man maximises, selects the best alternative from among all those available to him,” he wrote, “his cousin, administrative man, satisfices, looks for a......

Words: 687 - Pages: 3

Ir Paper

...decided to secede in order to prevent all this from happening. Neorealism explains this concept because this fear can be termed security dilemma which is the fear that states have because no state will want to subdue to another. However Neorealism does not explain the complication and contradiction of the war i.e. how and why the government of Nigeria wanted the war to just be a simple case of correction not fatal destruction. Ken Okolo, “Nigerian Civil War,” This Day”, 2000. Thirdly, the division of Nigerian into different tribes had an effect during the period of the civil war since it is a very normal happening for tribes to go at war with each other. Tribalism simply put is the possession of a strong cultural or ethnic identity that separates oneself as a member of one group from the members of another. Tribalism was one of the causes of the civil war because different states sought the same needs but their capabilities for which they could get such needs which are one of the principles of Neorealism differ. Furthermore tribalism set states in a constant awareness of each other since all states are in a race for survival and no state wants to be dependent on another. This was one of the motives for the civil war and is explained by the principle of Neorealism since states are seeking survival and the fear of being exploited drives the security dilemma. In addition Britain sought interest again in Nigeria because of the minerals that were present in the......

Words: 1499 - Pages: 6