Medical Ethics and Research

In: Other Topics

Submitted By kacynoble
Words 1492
Pages 6
Kacy Noble
Medical Research and Ethics
HCS/ 435
March 7, 2011
Patricia Tobin Ph.D., LCSW

Medical Research and Ethics
In the medical field ethics plays a large role in dictating what is deemed acceptable. The role of ethics has changed drastically over the past hundred years. There are many well-known unethical medical studies that have taken place in the past. Current research is being questioned by ethics professionals as well. The difference between now and then is our resources. Now, thee are ethics committees who help make these fragile decisions. Research much now be approved and follow rigorous standards. Ethics has changed drastically and will continue to evolve, hopefully for the better, in the future. Many of the well-known ethics cases involving research are highly publicized. The ethical research case I chose is not as well known. Possible reasons of the lack of publicity might be because the participants were not physically hurt nor were their health statuses altered. William Laud Humphreys managed to produce research that is ethically wrong in which none of the participants were named or harmed. Could this be why his research is still discussed in many universities today?
William Laud Humphreys was born October 16, 1930. Laud had two brothers whom he was never close to and did not have a favorable opinion of his father (TWU, 2010). Humphreys graduated from Seabury-Western theological seminary in 1955. He was then baptized and changed his name from William Laud to just “Laud”. Laud was ordained as and Episcopal priest and served several parishes post graduation. Laud later married and adopted two children with his wife, Nancy (Adam, 2006).
In the 1960’s Laud Humphreys was studying sociology and working toward a Ph.D. at Washington University. He was a doctoral candidate as well. Humphreys wanted to understand and maybe rationalize…...

Similar Documents

Medical Ethics

...Virtue ethics is one out of three major parts of normative ethics. As the word ‘virtue’ describes the whole concept of virtue ethics i.e. it points to a set of character which leads to good behaviour. It portrays the behaviour of an individual not overall society. It includes the behaviour of a person towards others and is based on moral characters and virtues. Virtue ethics helps in encouraging people to adapt good behaviour in order to attain a good life. It is not based on duties or consequences unlike other two normative ethics. Virtue ethics indicate to help other because it is the kind thing to do. For example helping a old women to cross the road, is the kind thing to do but in helping her you are not getting any benefit it just a act of kindness. Virtue ethics add lots to morality as sometimes, there is necessity to think more than duty and consequences as a life exist between a person’s duty and consequences. Ethics of care often considered a part of virtue ethics. This theory also describes the character of individual and not of society as whole. It is based on the emotional relation i.e. friendship, care etc of an individual with other people. It gives significance to humanity and relationship with human. Family comes in the first step of care ethics. For example if a person mother is suffering from cancer in the last stage, and plead to award her death in order to free her from suffering and not be more burden on other family members. Ethics of caring is......

Words: 314 - Pages: 2

Research Ethics

...preferences Document Viewer TurnitinOriginality Report Processed on: 22-Oct-2012 10:34 PM CDT ID: 278093834 Word Count: 390 Submitted: 1 business research ethicsBy Jere Gossom Similarity Index 0% What's this? Similarity by Source Internet Sources:0% Publications:0% Student Papers:N/A include quotedinclude bibliographyexclude small matchesdownloadrefreshprint mode:show highest matches together show matches one at a time quickview (classic) report Business Research Ethics Jere Gossom RES/351 10/22/2012 Mr. Warlick Business Research Ethics This paper will look to provide documentation of unethical research perpetrated against certain populations of the United States. During the research, promises of free treatment in regards to the study were promised, but were never given. In fact, when the cure was needed it was withheld. In 1932, The United States Public Health Service initiated a 40 year study, in which a series of experiments were conducted on 400 poor African Americans. These men were subjected to the syphilis without knowledge. The participants in the study were never informed of the risks, nor were they informed of the researches design. They were simply told they had “bad blood”. The unethical research behavior involved consisted of; one, not mentioning the risks involved; two, promising free treatment with no plan to do so; and three, lying and telling the gentlemen that they simply had “bad blood”. The......

Words: 484 - Pages: 2

Ethics in the Marketing of Medical Services

...Ethics in the Marketing of Medical Services STEPHEN R . LATHAM, J.D., PH.D. Abstract This paper deals with the ethics of marketing medical services by physicians, medical groups, hospitals and other mainstream medical caregivers in the United States. It does not deal with pharmaceutical marketing, since that raises a number of special issues, some of them legal and some having to do with the unique culture of pharmaceutical marketing, which really ought to be dealt with separately. Nor does it touch on the little-explored field of marketing alternative and complementary medicine. It begins with a general description of what is included in "the marketing process." It then briefly tours some of the difficulties faced by those who would market medical services ethically, and ends with some conunents on the relevance of professionalism to ethical marketing. Key Words: Professionalism, medical marketing, market competition, health care, product, placement, price, promotion, ethics. Marketing 101: The Four P's the idea of "marketing" with promotion and advertising. But in fact, "promotion" is only one of the famous "four P's of marketing" taught in most business schools. The first step in any marketing plan is to determine the nature of the Product (or service) one wishes to sell. Next, one determines its Placement, the distribution channels through which the product or service can best be made available to the consumer. Then, one attempts to determine the Price at which......

Words: 5524 - Pages: 23

Medical Ethics: History and Guiding Principals

...Title: Medical Ethics: History and Guiding Principles Author: Alan J. McGoldrick Course: Medicine, Disease and History Instructor: Professor Foss Date: June 15, 2012 Medical ethics are the moral guidelines and ethical laws that help to prioritize a medical professional's work responsibilities. The code of medical ethics outlines the proper conduct between medical professionals and their patients, communities, and colleagues. Each country has a different code of medical ethics, though most contain the same basic principles, and all share the same history of evolution, according to the World Medical Association. Medical ethics refers to the discussion and application of moral values and responsibilities in the areas of medical practice and research. While questions of medical ethics have been debated since the beginnings of Western medicine in the fifth century B.C., medical ethics as a distinctive field came into prominence only since World War II. (Porter, 1998) This change has come about largely as a result of advances in medical technology, scientific research, and telecommunications. These developments have affected nearly every aspect of clinical practice, from the confidentiality of patient records to end-of-life issues. Moreover, the increased involvement of government in medical research as well as the allocation of health care resources brings with it an additional set of ethical questions. Emerging Medical Ethics Through the Ages Ancient......

Words: 1879 - Pages: 8

Funding in Medical Research

...Canyon University: HLT- 364 10/11/13 As one studies medical research, they discovers that there are many problems surrounding it. However, one of them can make a tremendous impact, which are, budget cuts. When researching this problem, several questions came arise. How is budget cuts affecting health care administration? Why are there budget cuts? How are budget cuts effecting society? Lastly how was the budget used in the past and if the budget cuts were affected by the actions of those that run research facilities? There are several reasons to why budget is being cut and it is not just one problem that helps explain this. As one goes further into HealthCare research they come to the fact that there are problems that affect this one particular area overall. The first question that arises when inquiring about budget cuts in the health care administration is: Where is the funding they receive going? When there are so many budget cuts and there isn’t enough funding how is this affecting them? As one comes to inquire about budget cuts one has to understand that this affects the health care administration in many ways. As budget cuts arise, problems arise as well. When there is not sufficient money to go around then there are problems as to how much funding does each department receive. As the funding is divided there are shortages that arise. For example, there are shortages in the equipment supply that is needed. A research study indicated that after inquiring of how......

Words: 2486 - Pages: 10

Medical Ethics

...Jerry McCall Ethics Case Study Overview This is an USA pseudo-case diverged from the following Medical and Ethics Textbook case study in Ch. 4 of Medical Law and Ethics that gives insight to medical – ethics and their applications (Fremgen, 2010, p. 85). Jerry McCall is Dr. Williams’s office assistant. He has received professional training as both a medical assistant and an LPN. He is handling all the phone calls while the receptionist is at lunch. A patient calls and says he must have a prescription refill for Valium and that the provider, a friend, calls in the medication prior to any flights. This type of request happens often and in slightly different scenarios, but the outcome should remain the same to avoid ethical and legal issues. This paper will review the case study to help resolve the problem, the ethics involved, and the medical responsibility to refilling a prescription without provider authorization. Qualified Medical Training Understanding the definitions of a licensed practical nurse, LPN, and a medical assistant, MA is the first step to making a factual conclusion for this case study. Support staff to the provider cannot make decisions about medication refills for patients without a direct order from the provider. This action is outside the scope of practice for an LPN or MA. Licensed Practical Nurse An LPN is a role in support of the nurse or RN, a registered Nurse usually in a skilled nursing setting such as a hospital or long-term care facility...

Words: 1508 - Pages: 7

Medical Ethics and Euthanasia

...Medical Ethics and Euthanasia In his essay “When Medicine Is Futile” Barron H. Lerner talks about how dying patients in America, in his opinion can not have a peaceful death. Important role in his writing represents his dad and his thinking. He has a big influence on Lerner`s opinion about the medicine in general. He argues that people die too many times connected to all kinds of machines and tubes that don`t really help them. Lerner describes some of the stories that his father kept in the journals. They have one common thing, and that is that event though the doctors knew the patients is going to die, his family was still hoping for a miracle and they did not want to accept that there is nothing that the doctors can do, to save the patient`s life. Reading and thinking about Lerner`s article lead me to ask myself; is it really true that there are no chances at all to save any patient? I think we should all still keep faith and stay optimistic that things will go better, no matter what situation we find ourselves in. In connection to that when we think about medicine, here comes the controversial problem about euthanasia. Should it be legalized and what are the pros and cons of it? Euthanasia is one of the most pressing issues of modern society. The development of medicine has put humanity against serious dilemma where the use of medical resources no longer offers the cure. As it is developing in many areas, there are still those areas where we ask ourselves; what to......

Words: 712 - Pages: 3

Medical Ethics

...on their behalf, but there is no legal requirement for them to do so. If consent has been given validly, the lack of a completed form is no bar to treatment, but a form can be important evidence of such consent. Consent may also be expressed verbally or non-verbally. An example of non-verbal consent would be where a person, after receiving appropriate information, holds out an arm for their blood pressure to be taken. However, the person must have understood what examination or treatment is intended, and why, for such consent to be valid. It is good practice to obtain written consent for any significant procedure, such as a surgical operation or when the person participates in a research project or a video recording. All adults are presumed to have sufficient capacity to decide on their own medical treatment unless there is evidence to suggest otherwise, Capacity is the ability to use and understand information to make a decision and communicate any decision made. If a person lacks capacity their mind is impaired in some way which therefore means the person is unable to make a decision. This may include adults who suffer from Dementia, or bipolar disorder. It can also include patients who have severe learning disabilities or physical or mental conditions which cause certain symptoms like confusion, loss of consciousness. Patients can also lack capacity if they suffer from intoxication from drug and alcohol misuse. A patient with such an impairment is thought to be unable to...

Words: 986 - Pages: 4

Research on Ethics

...Ethics in Research We are going through a time of profound change in our understanding of the ethics of applied social research. From the time immediately after World War II until the early 1990s, there was a gradually developing consensus about the key ethical principles that should underlie the research endeavor. Two marker events stand out (among many others) as symbolic of this consensus. The Nuremberg War Crimes Trial following World War II brought to public view the ways German scientists had used captive human subjects as subjects in oftentimes gruesome experiments. In the 1950s and 1960s, the Tuskegee Syphilis Study involved the withholding of known effective treatment for syphilis from African-American participants who were infected. Events like these forced the reexamination of ethical standards and the gradual development of a consensus that potential human subjects needed to be protected from being used as 'guinea pigs' in scientific research. By the 1990s, the dynamics of the situation changed. Cancer patients and persons with AIDS fought publicly with the medical research establishment about the long time needed to get approval for and complete research into potential cures for fatal diseases. In many cases, it is the ethical assumptions of the previous thirty years that drive this 'go-slow' mentality. After all, we would rather risk denying treatment for a while until we achieve enough confidence in a treatment, rather than run the risk of harming innocent......

Words: 393 - Pages: 2

Medical Research

...JSLHR Research Article Lexical Effects on Children’s Speech Processing: Individual Differences Reflected in the Autism-Spectrum Quotient (AQ) Mitsuhiko Ota,a Mary E. Stewart,b Alexandra M. Petrou,b and Catherine Dickiec Purpose: This study was undertaken to examine whether children exhibit the same relationship that adults show between lexical influence on phoneme identification and individual variation on the Autism-Spectrum Quotient (AQ). Method: Data from 62 4- to 7-year-olds with no diagnosis of autism were analyzed. The main task involved identification of the initial sound in pairs of voice-onset time continua with a real word on one end and a nonword on the other (e.g., gift–kift, giss–kiss). Participants were also given the children’s version of the AQ and a 2nd instrument related to autistic-like traits, the Social Responsiveness Scale (SRS). Results: The lexical shift was related to the AQ (particularly to its Attention Switching subscale) but not to the SRS. Conclusions: The size of lexical effects on children’s speech perception can be predicted by AQ scores but not necessarily by other measures of autism-like traits. The results indicate that speech perception in children manifests individual differences along some general dimension of cognitive style reflected in the AQ, possibly in relation to local/global information processing. U Ota, 2008; Yu, 2010; Yu, Abrego-Collier, & Sonderegger, 2013). The Autism-Spectrum......

Words: 5913 - Pages: 24

Medical Assistant Ethics

...Association of Medical Assistants, offers a Certified Medical Assistant Certification for those who have obtained the required education through an accredited medical assistant program (American Association of Medical Assistants). The Medical Assistant’s professional Code of Ethics is a guide I can always refer back to when my ethical responsibilities are being tested, or when I am in doubt whether a certain situation is ethical or not. It is a reminder of why I choose this career, dedicating myself to the care and wellbeing of all people. For Medical Assistants, there are three certifying agencies available within the state of California, where I reside: American Association of Medical Assistants, where you can obtain a “NCCA” Accreditation (, American Medical Technologists RMA certification, where you can obtain a AMT certification (, and California Certifying Board of Medical Assistants where you can obtain a California Certified Medical Assistant (CCMA) certification ( The “Scope of Practice” determines the boundaries that a physician, or other medical professional practices. In entails the range of responsibilities and practice guidelines ( The American Association of Medical Assistants determines this ( Three of the standards of professionalism that are based on the codes of ethics for Medical Assistants are: Seek to continually improve the knowledge and skills of the......

Words: 368 - Pages: 2

Ethical Dilemma on Medical Research

...ETHICAL DILEMMA ON MEDICAL RESEARCH (HUMANS AS SUBJECTS) I am in favor of the medical research on humans/infants that could save or benefit future generations. For as long as the researcher would strictly adhere to three principles to ethically conduct a research on human subjects it would always be fine for me. The first principle is, the researcher must believe that the human subject in the experiment has at least the same chance of doing as well as a patient in standard therapy. Second, human subjects must be selected equitably in the sense that the researcher must avoid vulnerable populations, such as the very sick and the poor. I believe that using money as an inducement is unethical. Third, a researcher still has to have informed consent or to have a document and a process where he/she explains the procedure, the risks and the benefits to the subject – to the guardian given the subject is infant. The researcher must understand that the informed consent document does not evidence either that the participant is informed or that he/she consents. There is an ethical duty on the researcher to make sure that the subject understands the process and risks and is not coerced into giving consent. I definitely condemn medical researcher who believes that his/her work is so important that it justifies compromising the human subject. The abovementioned principles must be upheld at all times within such kind of research. Researchers for thousand years have abused human subjects to......

Words: 286 - Pages: 2

Medical and Ethics

...aspiring professional in the medical field, your understanding of these influential factors will help you become a valued asset to an organization.In this assignment you will practice what you have learned in chapters 4, 6, and 8 in the Medical Law and Ethics textbook: * Legal and ethical boundaries * Federal and state legislation * Federal and state regulations | Tips for answering questions: * Read the question more than twice, if necessary, to make sure you understand what you are asked to do. * Find the key words in the question and construct your answer to address those key words or phrases of the question. * Your answer should be organized and to the point. * Keep your sentences short and simple. Pay attention to the answer length requirements (if stated). * If necessary, go the extra mile and give examples to illustrate your point. | Before you continue: * Did you save this document to your computer? * No: Please save this document to your computer now. * Yes: Great! Let’s get to work! | (See next page for part 1) Question 1: What is the difference between an HMO and a PPO? | 6 points | Directions to complete Question 1: * Please answer the question in 2-3 sentences * Respond to the question using your own words | Answer:Type your answer hereThe difference is That HMOs don’t offer coverage For care From an out of network physician, hospital or Facility except in The case of a True medical emergency. However, with a......

Words: 1442 - Pages: 6

Medical Ethics simple as being able to learn at their own pace. In my case I love taking online classes because I am able to take more classes towards my degree without having to be on campus every day. Also, since I work full-time, online classes make it much easier for me to balance my work and school schedule. When I was making my schedule for fall semester and I knew that I needed to take this class, I have to tell you I was very excited. I know from working in the medical field that many different and challenging situations arise and need to be addressed properly, that is where medical ethics comes into play. During this semester I learned about multiple different issues, thoughts, beliefs and reasons on how we should deal with certain situations. But, there were two things that struck me and make me think when I am at work dealing with patients and their families. Medical ethics is defined as a system of moral principles that apply values and judgments to the practice of medicine. As a learned discipline, medical ethics encompasses its everyday use in clinical settings as well as work on its history, philosophy, theology, and sociology. There are several moral principles and values that help to provide a framework for understanding conflicts. . If you look at each of them individually, one cannot survive without the other. Because of this each one helps to make the moral system effective. Of the three moral principles (autonomy, beneficence, justice), the one that......

Words: 1236 - Pages: 5

Medical Research

...organization of information in the medical research p aper have tended to present accounts of the structure of information in s ections in isolation. The structure of information in all sections of the medical r esearch paper was investigated using Swales' (1981, 1990) genre-analysis m odel. An eleven-move schema was identified, out of which nine were found t o be "normally required" and two "optional". Each schema was found to e mbody "constituent elements" and to be characterized by distinct linguistic f eatures. The study provides insights into the nature of discourse organization in this genre of written discourse. © 1997 The American University. Published b y Elsevier Science Ltd I ntroduction A s with most experimental research reports, the medical research paper is a highly technical form with a standard format for the presentation of i nformation. This format is the division of the paper into "Introduction, M ethods, Results and Discussion" - - the traditional IMRD sections of the r esearch paper. M ost research article writers are familiar with the IMRD format, but not all are conscious of the fact that there exists an internal ordering of the i nformation presented in the various sections of the research article. This l ack of awareness may account partly for the difficulty which most writers, e specially new entrants into the academic discourse community face with p roducing clear, coherent and logically organized research reports. A n umber......

Words: 9805 - Pages: 40