Indigenes Film Critique

In: Film and Music

Submitted By liyingq
Words 523
Pages 3
Film Critique #2 Indigenes
This film tells a story about four African soldiers, Said, Ardelaker, Messaoud and Yassir, who fought for France in World War II. As the film going on, audiences start to know the little-known history about Indigenes through these four African soldiers’ life story.

They joined the war for various reasons. Said joined the war to survive. As he said he is “from total poverty”, and he at least can have something to eat in the army. Yassir joined the army for money. During the battle he was busy to pick up watches and other belongings of died German soldiers. Ardelaker and Messaoud joined the war for the loyalty to France, just as most of other African soldiers. They want to fight for France; even this is the country they have never seen, they still think they are “the children of the fatherland”.

However, their attitudes changed during the war because of the identity recognition and Discrimination. I think it is also the main themes of these films. These soldiers consider themselves as French citizens, but French military treats them as second-class soldiers. In the scene of they dining on a ship, the French officer refuse to offer North African soldier tomato for their meal. Ardelaker had a fight with his officer, but it not just because of a tomato, he want to be treat equally as his “French brother”. Ironically, after that, they heard the news of the victory from the radio, and they proudly sang the French national anthem together with their “French brothers”. It is pathetic because France does not and will never treat them as “own children”, and they just using their patriotism to fight for France.

This film portrays this discrimination and self-recognition of African soldiers in many times. For example, they never got promotion no matter how loyal and brave they were during the battle, because the military only give promotion…...

Similar Documents

Film Critique

...FILM CRITIQUE (Final Version) Mona Lisa Smile At the very first glance, the title “Mona Lisa Smile” gives me an impression of mysterious and controversial, which is exactly the same as the famous painting by Leonardo da Vinci. This impression inspires me to watch the whole film excitedly. The film does show a great 1950s period with the brilliant cast performance. The leading character, Katherine Ann Watson (Julia Roberts) is amazing. She is a very special woman who is the center of the whole story. She wants to make difference at Wellesley College - one of the most conservative institutions in the USA by encouraging the girls there to think more for themselves and make their own choices out of the tradition. It can be seen that Julia Robert really succeeds in showing Katherine’s psychological process. At the beginning of the film, Katherine appears to be very calm and independent woman; she strongly believes in the progressive thinking and supposes it will be good for all of her students. But as the story is coming to the end, I can realize that actually Katherine is not so sure about herself, especially after her student, Joan (Julia Stiles) decides to get married instead of going to law school as Katherine recommended. Even though Katherine follows the new movement, there are still some traditional ideas inside that prevent her from totally getting out of the conservative opinions and finding her own way. It is quite reasonable as the 1950s is the transforming period...

Words: 360 - Pages: 2

Gran Torino Film Critique

...Gran Torino Film Critique ENG 225 March 17, 2013 Gran Torino Film Critique Gran Torino is a drama about redemption, helping others, and demonstrates how we are all the same regardless of cultural differences. The movie focuses on the relationship Walt develops with his Hmong neighbors. Walt manages to strategically save the life of the boy next door, Thao. Walt helps Thao get his life back on track. Thao has been coerced to partake into his cousin’s gang. The gang forces Thao to steal Walt’s Gran Torino. Once Walt finds Thao in his garage trying to steal his Gran Torino, he knows that something has gone wrong with Thao. At this point, the drama in the story soars, as Walt begins his personal quest to protect Thao. Walt tries his best not to reveal that he has a caring soul but that he is an angry and grumpy old man. Later the film reveals that Walt is the complete opposite of angry and grump. As the story unfolds and the gangbangers return and Walt reaches for his gun, the film moves from comedy, drama, tragedy, and then into something unexpected. Nick Schenk wrote Gran Torino and his inspiration with the Hmong culture. Schenk placed a Hmong family next door to a Korean War veteran. The main story line develops as the Korean War veteran (Clint Eastwood) learns to adapt and interact with the Hmong family. Clint Eastwood directed, produced, and starred in the drama Gran Torino. Clint Eastwood began his acting career in low budget films in 1955. In 1959...

Words: 2324 - Pages: 10

Film Critique

...Final Film Critique: Light it up, 1998 M.parker ENG 225: Introduction to Film Instructor: Jenessa Gerling January 21, 2013 Final Film Critique A critic is one who should educate others what the meaning of a film is so viewers can form their own educated opinion about it. Koontz & Jacobs, 2011 states “the local critic should be part of a community discussion, not as the final word on the matter, but merely a starting point” (Koontz & Jacobs, 2011). This critique will discuss the movie Light it up and how this movie is a reflection of problems faced by youth in American society at the turn of the 21st Century. Light it up takes place in the late 90’s in New York City. The story begins with one of the main characters Ziggy giving the audience a background on each of the other six main characters. After learning of the characters backgrounds the movie is then brought into the present day. Starting out at Lincoln High, which is the school that all of the main characters attend in one way or another. The audience is introduced to the poor condition that the school has been allowed to slip into. Not only is the school in an almost uninhabitable condition, the principle has also hired policemen to be on guard full time during school hours to keep the “peace”. The picture that is painted for the audience in the first five minutes of this film is not a very good one. As a viewer you are shown and made to believe that these kids are low life thugs who are nothing......

Words: 1948 - Pages: 8

Film Critique

...Lambs: Film Critique Midari Marrero ENG 225 Intro to Film Instructor: Julie Pal-Agrawal June 25, 2012 It is uncommon in our day to find horror movies that can compare to the critically acclaimed film of Jonathan Demme's 1991 The Silence of the Lambs, starring Anthony Hopkins as Dr. Hannibal Lecter, the infamous and psychotic cannibal psychiatrist. This movie, along with Alfred Hitchock's Psycho (1960), is one of limited horror/suspense films recognized by movie critics as one of the greatest American films ever made. Critics had much to say about the “commercialization” of one of the most horrifyingly amazing characters in the history of American theatre, but even more interesting is the change that is specified through the character's approval in mainstream culture. Hannibal Lecter is a different type of monstrous cannibal than those formerly seen in horror films, as shown through his criminal activities, and has been acknowledged by its viewers as an “anti-hero” as opposed to the adversary or antagonist of the movie. The story line behind this movie captured the audience to want to watch this disgusting anti-human film, which included cannibalism. Everyone that was involved in the creation of this film from the film director, cinematographer, art editors, sound directors, the costumes the staging everyone had to be in that same dark place in order to make this a captivating need to watch film. In the following pages I would like to describe scenes of the film and by...

Words: 1884 - Pages: 8

Film Critique

...She-Devil Introduction to Film She-Devil “I’ve worked so hard for! You’re bad mother, a lousy wife, a terrible cook! In fact, have you looked in a *mirror* recently?! I don’t even know you’re a woman. You know what you are? You’re a She-Devil!” I’m sure there many women how have seen She-Devil starring Rosanne Barr as Ruth Patchett, Ed Begley Jr. as Bob Pactchett and Meryl Streep as Mary Fisher said, “That couldn’t have been me.” The screenplay for the 1989 movie was written by Susan Seidelman, based on a novel by Fay Weldon. She-Devil tells the story of “a cunning and resourceful housewife vows revenge on her husband when he begins an affair with a wealthy romance novelist.” According to an unnamed source, to the movie received mixed reviews and was criticized the film for its tone. Both Barr and Streep were given positive feedback for their performances, however, Streep earned a Golden Globe Award nomination as Best Actress in a Musical or Comedy 1990. Even though some individuals may feel that the movie is one-side gender related. Recommending people to see this movie because this movie contains many positive/negative aspects of everyday life for both men and women. And this film can also help a couple that is having and want to fix things the "right" way. In She Devil, Ruth Patchett (Rosanna Barr) suspects her husband, Robert Patchett (Ed Begley Jr.) is having an affair after taking a very attractive novelist Mary Fisher (Meryl Streep) home from his accountant......

Words: 2827 - Pages: 12

Film Review Critique

...Film review rebuttal Objective: to use current level of knowledge regarding film (production, marketing, distribution, editing, sound, cinematography, elements of miser-en-scene, narrative etc.) rebut or critique the opinion of a professionally prepared film with which you personally disagree. Rebuttal critique guidelines: the paper should be at least three full pages, excluding supporting material and citation pages. the paper should be written in an essay format- that is, an opening thesis paragraph clearly stating paper�s intent, points to be covered, and direction; followed by well-developed paragraphs on each concept to be covered; and ending with a clear summery and conclusion. Direction: choose a film which you believe peer audience commonly would or should see and appreciate. Recent films are preferred (in the last three years) American films only. After you have selected a film, find a review of the film which you disagree with in whole or in part. The review to rebut must be written by a professional reviewer (a fan posting to a blog is not a professional review, for instance.) your disagreement with the said film review may address factors you believed the original reviewer left out or did not develop well enough. A copy of the review used must be attached to the final draft of the essay. Film review content and focus: the paper�s focus should be to write a rebuttal to the professional review chosen. The rebuttal review must cite at least three points in which you......

Words: 394 - Pages: 2

Final Film Critique

...Week 5: Final Film Critique ENG 225: Introduction to Film Instructor Stephanie Miclot 03 Mar 2014 I have chosen the film Armageddon as the final film critique in this course. Armageddon was released to the America in 1998. The film was directed by Michael Bay, and written by J.J. Abrams and Jonathan Hensleigh. While there were a number of high-profile actors in this film, the undoubtedly biggest stars in this film were Bruce Willis, Billy Bob Thorton, Ben Affleck, and Liv Tyler. (Imdb, 2008). Armageddon was a movie with a lot of potential, that was poorly written from the start and dismally executed on screen. While I am a fan of quite a few cast members, I was disappointed with this film as a whole. Albeit the storyline certainly lineal, the entire movie was fragmented with action sequences that left the audience wondering just exactly what was going on. “Take almost any 30 seconds at random, and you’d have a TV ad.” (Ebert, 2008, para.1). Armageddon seems to have been tossed together in haphazardly fashion by it’s writers, replacing real scientific facts with your typical inaccurate, and dramatized hollywood one-liners fired off by the actors in this film at every turn. An example of the diluted science in this film is in the plot of the story itself. An asteroid the size of the state of Texas is cutting through space on course for a head on collision with Earth, at which point, is certain to destroy our planet, and end......

Words: 2322 - Pages: 10

Film Critique

...certain that her students learn what happened during World War II. After reading The Story of Anne Frank and visiting a Holocaust museum, the students realize that like them, others have suffered greatly. It was not easy to watch this movie at times as pictures and stories from the Holocaust were hard to imagine, especially knowing that the lives of millions of people were lost and families were destroyed, forever! A visit to the students from a woman who actually helped survivors of the Holocaust was so moving. She made quite an impression on Erin’s students as they thought of her as a hero. When in reality, she thought of the students as true heroes dealing with and surviving what they live through each day. The film is both moving and encouraging as it brought out what others live through each and every day. The story gives an excellent depiction of the hardships of the students while also sharing how they overcame their daily struggles with the help of a caring and devoted teacher. Two-time Academy Award® Hillary Swank gave an outstanding performance as teacher Erin Gruwell. Her portrayal of this selfless individual was authentic and inspiring. This was especially admirable knowing that she faced the challenge of going through a divorce while continuing in her quest of excellence for her students. What was so encouraging was finding out at the end of the movie that Erin’s fight to continue to teach and be with her......

Words: 580 - Pages: 3

Film Critique

...roles in films sequel Aliens ,Ghost Busters, Working Girl and super blockbuster –Avatar. Her role in the movie Alien .At the beginning of the movie Ripley with a role as a security officer does not stand out against the other team members. Her star role begins from the episode ,when a risky group was return with fixed crew member after the attack on him by unknown organism .Ripley trying to prevent the penetration of alien organism aboard a space ship. After this episode, the officer Ripley converts to the main hero in this movie. She takes the lead role in the organizing of the search, and then the destruction of the alien organism. She is the only member of the crew o f" NOSTROMO", who is survive. Sigourney Weaver, does a genuine job as an actor in movie “Alien”. From Disclosure of nature ...... we see step by step her expenditures From a quiet officer team of a Nostromo ,she . goes to the role of the main character, struggling with extraterrestrial aggressive form of life. The crew of the ship becomes one .No mechanism, as in the classic horror film, all die ..... and got the role of the hero, which In 1986, Weaver reprises her Ripley role for the Alien sequel, Aliens, which garnered the star an Academy Award nomination for best actress. Two years later, Weaver garnered two more Oscar nominations—in the best actress category for her performance in Gorillas in the Mist, and in the best supporting actress category for her portrayal of Katharine Parker in the film......

Words: 749 - Pages: 3

Film Critique

...Film Critique: The Education of Shelby Knox Destiny Matvenko-Barbini AP/HREQ 1800 Veronika Novoselova York University Film Critique: The Education of Shelby Knox The film The Education of Shelby Knox is a documentary that tells a story of a girl named Shelby, who tries to fight to have sex education put into public schools of Lubbock, Texas by joining a youth commission. By joining the youth commission and trying to campaign the right to get sex education, there were a few bumps in the road, like having the campaign also fight for gay rights. But nothing stopped her and she kept fighting. The central theme of this film is the lack of sex education, and not having it in public schools. This theme is important because Shelby thinks it would be a good idea to add it so more people to have a better understanding of what sex really is. Throughout the film, the lack of sex education can be analyzed by what social issues it causes and why the issues are important, how sex education challenges the notion of child innocence, the sociological concepts that are helpful in understanding the film’s message and what king of social impact the film seeks to achieve and examine what questions for further discussions it rises. By analyzing this, it will give us an indication on why sex education should be put into the schools of Lubbock. In the film, according to Shelby, “one in fourteen teenage girls getting pregnant” (The Education of Shelby Knox), in Lubbock, Texas, which leads to...

Words: 1127 - Pages: 5

Jerry Macguire Film Critique

...Jerry Maguire – Film Critique Teri Reed ENG225: Introduction to Film Instructor Daniel Burrello February 9, 2015 Jerry Maguire – Film Critique It takes several people to make a movie, from the Actors to the Directors, Writers and Producers, and to the Production Company, all of which are equally important to making a movie successful. There is a mixture of technical skills, while building strong relationships with trust, and following the personal vision of the director who serves as a master facilitator in editing and on the set. All of these people help the director to form the story in the film. A countless amount of time is put into a film’s analysis which observes the filmmaking techniques, in turn helps the audience to understand the style of the film. A film's style is a dependable on the cinematic methods that include the mise en scène, cinematography, editing, sound, and overall structure (Goodykoontz & Jacobs 2014). Filmmaker’s styles have advanced so much over many years in Hollywood, and they have incorporated many elements of all sorts of technical effects while developing distinctive approaches to making a movie. Director Cameron Crowe offers an inspiring thematic trio in the movie Jerry Maguire, it is filled with drama, comedy, and romance as it relates to a genre film. Cameron Crowe did his homework before he began to develop the character Jerry Maguire. He talked to a businessmen and interviewed him for about a year in order to develop the......

Words: 2578 - Pages: 11

Film Critique

...Brown Sugar Mary Smith ENG225: Introduction to Film Prof Nathan Pritts August 26, 2015 Brown Sugar A girl and boy who have been lifelong friends A&R Andre and Editor in Chief Sidney attribute their friendship to the day they fell in love with hip hop music.  Time as past and the friendship has remained in tack despite their different career paths.  It has been fifteen years later and Sidney moves returns home where she is now Chief and Editor of XXL magazine only to find out that the love of hip-hop is not the only thing that brings them back together again. Brown Sugar plot revolves around the relationship between Sidney (Sannaa Lathan) and Dre (Taye Diggs) who have been childhood friends.  Sidney has taken the position of editor and chief of the hip-hop magazine XXL back in her home town Brooklyn.  Dre is a partner in a music label called Millennium Records.  Upon Sidney return to Brooklyn Dre reveals that he is preparing to marry Reese (Nicole Ari Parker) who is a successful entertainment attorney.  This news sends Sidney into a subconscious tizzy. Sidney going forward after hearing the news of Dre getting married finds herself struggling to interact with Dre.  After hanging out before his wedding Sidney impulsively kiss Dre and from that kiss lead them to a confusing night of intimacy and cracking doubt about everything between them.  Dre goes through with the wedding and tries to settle in with his new wife and life.  While in pursuit of a new artist Dre is...

Words: 2128 - Pages: 9

Film Critique

...Critique: BTTF Mathew Peppersack ENG 225 Introduction to Film Professor Ryan Ogrodnik March 2, 2015 Critique: BTTF To critique a film is to analyze the substance of what makes up the movie. The story and its plot, characters, technical choices for scenes, and the overall production that the film shown to give the audience a final product. The number of people who visited the movie theater to watch it does not determine greatness of the film; or the amount of money the movie studio made after the budget was settled. A movie is great if it reached a large percentage of the population and that population determined through criticism and good reviews that the movie is worthy to be seen for a second, third, or fourth time. Another justification of greatness is if the film warrants purchasing the film on Blu-ray disc or a digitally copy to put on your computers hard drive. I will be critiquing the 1985 film Back to the Future starring Michael J. Fox, Christopher Lloyd, Lea Thompson, Crispin Glover, and Thomas F. Wilson. These are the main characters of the film for which the story revolves around. Michal J. Fox plays the main character, Marty McFly, who travels back in time in a Delorean time machine invented by Christopher Lloyd’s character, Dr. Emmett Brown. Lea Thompson plays Lorraine McFly, Marty’s mother, Crispin Glover plays George McFly, Marty’s father. Thomas F. Wilson is the antagonist as Biff Tannen. There are plenty of supporting roles throughout the film......

Words: 2605 - Pages: 11

Film Critique Final Paper

...Film Critique: INSIDIOUS Intro to Film 225 Vera Baber Instructor: BradWaltman February 12, 2012 If you are looking for a good horror film to sit down and cuddle up with, and you aren’t bent on happy or predictable endings, Insidious is a gem that will not only scare and surprise you, but keep you thinking and without all the blood and gore that most horror films rely on these days. INSIDIOUS is a film about a family who moves into a new home and begins to experience some very strange phenomenon, such as items being moved from one place to another without any explanation. The setting is an old creepy house; with an attic full of items from the past, and which seems to draw people in; first the mother, then the son. The son Dalton ends up falling off of a ladder while playing in the attic. He seems to receive only a minor bump from the fall, but during the night while asleep in his bed, he mysteriously drifts off into a coma and is unresponsive when his parent try to wake him for school. He is then rushed to the hospital emergency room where his condition baffles doctors. They cannot understand why there is no brain damage which is usually accompanied with a coma, but they have no idea what else to call it. He is ultimately sent home to be cared for by his mother with the help of a part-time nurse. It is during this time that the paranormal activity really kicks off in the story. Most of the paranormal occurrences seem to take place during the day while the mother is......

Words: 1550 - Pages: 7

Final Film Critique

...(ENG 225 Introduction to Film) Final Film Critique (Due Sept 11, 2012) Review the critical analysis questions in the “Conclusion and Critic’s Resource” section of your textbook. Write an eight to ten page film critique (excluding the cover and reference pages) of an American feature film of your choosing. Use the list of critical analysis questions provided in your textbook as a guide while writing your paper. Areas that must be covered: • Storytelling • Acting • Cinematography • Editing • Sound • Style and Directing • Impact of society on the film and vice versa • Genre • Application of at least one approach to analysis and interpretation • Overall textual themes Writing Tips: • Students must select a film that they have not previously explored in class, either in written assignments or discussion posts. • Students must establish a coherent thesis statement in the introduction of their paper with a claim that they intend to prove. The body of the essay serves to support the thesis through an analysis of the film and other relevant material. Avoid simply rehashing descriptive material from other source. • Support your thesis through textual and formal analysis. Refer to specific shots, scenes, characters, stylistic devices, and themes in the film. • As much as possible, use technical, literary and industry terms to make your points. • If needed, you may use additional resources to support your claims. Suggested sources might include......

Words: 450 - Pages: 2