Conscience Is a Product of Upbringing. Discuss

In: Religion Topics

Submitted By ayocrownn
Words 1480
Pages 6
Conscience is a product of upbringing. Discuss.
The idea that childhood is a product of upbringing is supported by secular approaches from Piaget, Freud and Fromm, in inferring the idea that conscience has nothing to do with religion; rather it is to do with upbringing. However there are responses to these secular approaches coming from Newman, Aquinas and Butler who infer the idea that conscience is a voice from God, a God given ability or a natural guide to decision making. This essay will assess both approaches and their weigh them up based on their coherence. * Piaget- learned
Piaget put forward the idea that conscience is learned. He was a developmental psychologist who studied the behaviour of children. He theorised that children go through different stages in their understanding of the world around them, and it is not till the age of 10 that young people have fully developed a sense of morality. This scientific approach is very plausible because it is based on observations, and makes predictions that can be tested. For instance, you can describe two different situations to a six year old, one of which is lying causing a minor consequence and the other is someone causing a very negative consequence. The latter would 'make mummy more cross' for a six year old, because their understanding is that something is bad if it hurts people. If you ask an older child, they would say the parent would be more cross with the child who told a lie. This shows that conscience for Piaget is something we learn as we grow and develop; thus a product of upbringing because it is determined by the rearing practices of a parent that shapes the ways in which they grow and develop. * Newman- contradicts Piaget- voice of God
This theory seems to contradict Newman's ideas. Newman was an intuitionist, believing that conscience is the voice of God. He believed that when faced…...

Similar Documents

Conscience and Moral Judgement

...things that cause stress, to be more efficient in our thinking, and to make better decisions to a certain degree. There is significant importance behind the understanding of the behaviours of the mind and cognitive processes of which it will experience, though it is the conscience that has been questioned whether it alone can be considered as a satisfactory moral authority for making ethical decisions. The answer to this lies within one’s own interpretation of what conscience actually is, though through consideration of various theories, conscience can be classed as a viable moral authority. There are various sources which define conscience in different manners; therefore this essay will review a selection of theories produced by Sigmund Freud, and Thomas Aquinas, whilst providing alternate viewpoints inclusive of those of the Islamic religion derived from scripture and also making reference to law and the effect it has on making moral decisions. Conscience can be defined as “the complex of ethical and moral principles that controls or inhibits the actions or thoughts of an individual”, though how we develop these ethical and moral principles will allow one to gather an understanding of how the conscience operates (Encarta Dictionary). Sigmund Freud was a Jewish psychiatrist famed as the founding father of psychoanalysis, which essentially describes that human behaviour, experience, and cognition are largely determined by irrational drives which are fundamentally......

Words: 1262 - Pages: 6

Discuss Wether Price Is the Main Factor Affecting Demand of a Consumer Product

...Discuss whether price is the main factor affecting the demand for Pepsi The question is telling us to discuss the whether price is the main factor which would affect the demand (the quantity of Pepsi consumers are willing to buy each month or so) for the product in this case Pepsi, this basically means to analyse the alternate factors (non price) which would also alter the demand for the product for example: price of substitute, the quality of substitute, the number of substitute, the quality, the customers income, trend of the time and also factors such as the price of the complement (a product bought with my product i.e. an association). Which in this case would be a complementary food item, like a chocolate bar or sandwich, as Pepsi may be part of a meal deal involving these category of items. The factors which will affect the demand can most generally be categorised into two groups ‘price’ and ‘non-price’ factors, and can most simply be categorised into having two affects on demand these being a direct affect (if this goes up or down the demand will move in sync) which are always non-price as price is an inverse factor which means if it rises or falls the demand will move in the opposite direction. In sum an increase in demand is caused by either an increase in a direct factor, examples: quality, income, advertising and price of substitutes, and a decrease in an inverse factor, examples: quality of substitute, price of complements. And a decrease is caused by......

Words: 1591 - Pages: 7

Conscience Is the Voice of God Within Us

...‘Conscience is the voice of God within us’ Discuss In order to discuss whether the conscience is the result of the voice of God within us or whether in fact it is the result other environmental or biological factors we must firstly understand what a conscience is. Conscience is defined as a ‘direct intuitive awareness of right and wrong’ and therefore it is a ‘way of selecting moral ideas, resolving conflict and deciding which will work or not’. The conscience itself has three main functions, the first is that it has a decision-making function; this is seen as the most important function as it decides between right and wrong, the second is that it has a imperative functions; that is it commands and the third is that it has a reflective function; that is that it reflects on former decisions and considers the consequences of actions. However the question raised within this essay is whether our conscience comes from the voice of God within us, therefore is it acquired from God and is the result of an internal influence or is it required as a result of environmental factors, therefore is formed from an external influence whether this is from our parents or our own life experiences. Within this essay I shall discuss the theories in favour of the conscience being the voice of God within us (focussing on Butler, Augustine and Newman), and those that instead propose that it is acquired from other sources whether this is through our reason (Aquinas) or in our early childhood......

Words: 3118 - Pages: 13

Children's Upbringing

...Children's upbringing We start in the first text called Why I love my strict Chinese mom from a newspaper. It is an inter-view from The New York Post interviewing Sophia Chua-Rubenfeld who describes her up-bringing as a child. She had a very strict mother who used methods as not letting the children attend sleep-overs, have play dates, be in school plays, complain about not being in a school play. The daughter goes on telling the interviewer that she does not think that her mother rose her badly, as most of society does. She thinks that the mother did a really good job and that she in no way have lost any possibilities of friendship and fun. The method the mother uses is to have a strict scheme of what the children can and cannot do which, in the end, turned out great for her kids who says "If I died tomorrow, I would die feeling I've lived my whole life at 110 percent." The second text is called Let them eat pizza: parenting guru's recipe for bringing up children. Dr Bryan Caplan claims that activities such as music lessons, organized sports and educational games are a waste of time as they do not make the slightest difference to children when they mature. Parents should relax and give the children more slack and take a backseat role in the children's lives. Although he does subtly state that parents should make an effort to interact with their children until the age of 12 where after "it has no effect" The third and last text is a general policy statement from the......

Words: 813 - Pages: 4

Discuss Factors Affecting Product Pricing Ih the Uk

...Discuss factors affecting product pricing in the UK. Product pricing in the UK is dependent on several factors. Market structures such as monopoly and oligopoly play a major part in setting price. Market structures can then influence the objectives and behavior within a firm (Sloman & Wride, 2009). This can lead to the use of different pricing strategies, thus having varied effects on the level of price set. Traditional theory suggests that a firms’ main objective is profit maximization. Therefore, prices will be set in line to meet this objective. A monopoly is defined as one dominant firm in the industry. In theory, a monopoly will have inelastic demand due to no available substitutes. Therefore the firm will be a “price maker”. They can use their market power to control price and raise it to a level where price is greater than marginal cost (Sloman & Wride, 2009). Average cost     Marginal cost Average revenue Marginal revenue Output Price 0 Q1 P1 Average cost     Marginal cost Average revenue Marginal revenue Output Price 0 Q1 P1 Source: Adapted from Sloman & Wride, 2009. Fig.1. Diagram shows that a profit maximizing monopoly has the ability to profit maximize where marginal cost equals marginal revenue, and will therefore produce at output (Q1). Hence they will charge price (P1) that consumers are willing and able to pay for Q1. At price P1, the monopolist is making excess profit (highlighted). In perfect competition......

Words: 1173 - Pages: 5

Discuss the Main Factors Affecting Product Pricing in the Uk

...Product pricing is the price fixed upon a product by producers or suppliers to achieve sales in order to gain profit. There are a number of factors affecting product pricing in the UK. The first factor is the structure of the market. Oligopoly is a type of market that can be seen in the UK, for example, electricity and gas supply industry in Britain. Oligopoly is a market structure where there are few enough firms to enable barriers to be erected against the entry of new firms. Firms will come together (collude) and try to maximise their joint profits either by a formal agreement or tacit. However, formal agreements are illegal in the UK and it may also be unstable to due incentive for individual member firms to ‘cheat’. Non-collusive oligopoly is when firms do not collude and work independently for their own businesses. Firms are, however, interdependent when it comes to pricing policy. There is a variety of models to explain non-collusive oligopoly. The first model is the Cournot model where one firm changes its output, assuming their rival firm will keep their output fixed. There is also the Bertrand model which is when one firm changes its output in assumption that their rival firm will keep their prices fixed. Lastly, the kinked demand theory shows how price reduction of a firm is followed by others but not an increase in price. Figure 1 shows the kinked demand diagram but it does not show how price P1 and quantity Q1 came to exist. Figure 1 Another type of......

Words: 1160 - Pages: 5

Discuss the Main Factors Affecting Product Pricing in the Uk

...Discuss the main factors affecting product pricing in the UK (1000 words) Two surveys on the price-setting behaviour of UK firms published by the Bank of England in 1996 and 2008 concluded that the price, the amount of money expected, required or given for a certain level of output, was most often set as a result of market conditions. The same report however found that the second largest price differential was the objective of the specific firm surveyed, and thus product pricing in the UK can be seen to be determined primarily by the objectives of its firms, which are bounded by the differing market structures under which they operate. In the UK these dominant structures are monopolistic, oligopolistic and perfectly competitive, within which there are differing degrees of price setting ability and inter-firm competition, both of which influence the individual objectives the firms choose to pursue. As witnessed in recent years with the impact of the global recession however, all markets are vulnerable to external shocks to their product pricing. The classical theory of the firm assumes that they will pursue the objective of profit maximisation. As Milton Friedman put it in his 1970 article, ‘‘There is one and only one social responsibility of business - to use its resources in activities designed to increase its profits so long as it... engages in open and free competition without deception or fraud’1. Within a profit-maximising objective, the price charged will still......

Words: 1233 - Pages: 5

‘Food Insecurity Is Primarily a Product of a Country’s Level of Development’ Discuss

...‘Food insecurity is primarily a product of a country’s level of development’ Discuss Introduction Food insecurity exists whenever the availability of nutritionally adequate and safe foods or the ability to acquire acceptable foods in socially acceptable ways is limited or uncertain (www.who.int). The Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) further defines food security as being built on four pillars; food availability, food access, food utilization and stability. Each of these aspects arguably depends on the development of the country, therefore it can be said that food security is ‘a complex sustainable development issue’ (www.who.int). A country’s level of development takes into consideration factors such as its economic state (GDP etc.), political state, population size, education and technological advances. Each of these factors defining a countries development are crucial is sustaining food security, as a result a correlation can be drawn between food insecurity and development. On the other hand, development levels do not always determine food security of a country. It must be realised that even within developed countries food insecurity is still a problem, especially with widening gaps between the rich and poor. Furthermore external factors, such as war, can hugely disrupt food security in both MEDC’s and LEDC’s. Aid, usually given to food insecure LEDC’s, can also improve a less developed country’s food security, however usually this is not a long term or......

Words: 843 - Pages: 4

Conscience Is a Reliable Guide to Ethical Decision Making. Discuss.

...The question as to whether or not conscience is a reliable guide to ethical decision making can be approached in several ways and often only reaches a personal conclusion fueled by opinion. There are a number of ways in which conscience can be defined, one of which comes from Vincent Macnamara and is considered one of the more modern definitions, it is as follows. Macnamara says the conscience is not a voice but an attitude, he criticised Aquinas for referring to it as a “faculty” we possess. Macnamara regarded life as a moral path and said “it is up to us how we follow it”, furthermore he believes the attitude of our conscience shouldn't revolve around pleasure and profit. His belief is similar, in a way, to the virtue ethics approach and unfortunately boasts the same flaws, where it is hard to determine what is a virtue and what isn't, it's equally difficult to determine whether or not the attitude of our conscience is genuine. Another theory, put forward by Freud, and later developed by Piaget and Fromm, argues that conscience is more likely a result of environmental factors. This is typical of Freud's beliefs as he was first and foremost a psychologist and scientist with little time for the supernatural or divine. Sigmund Freud's definition of conscience links closely to a human beings feelings of guilt and fear of punishment, this suggests that people may act in order to get approval and could be easily seen as an unreliable guide to ethical decision making. Freud......

Words: 1022 - Pages: 5

Upbringing Children in Kazakhstan

...special attention to education of the young generation. From an early age they pawned a sense of patriotism, love of country, respect for elders, support youth. The role of grandparents in the upbringing, which, pampering and loving grandchildren, telling them stories, legends, true story of the brave men, bis, and thus is born in them a sense of imitation, love of work empathy, responsibility, morality. A grandfather required knowledge by heart seven generations of ancestors, in order not to spoil the blood. People brought up children, gradually accustomed to labor, to the subsequent generation of grown-up have taken care of the elders. The environment also influenced the formation of the person, so the children were taught to choose the right friends. If there are not good friends, then parents try to save their child. And one of the important aspects in the education of every child is the desire to achieve the goal. Mistakes senior strictly pointed at them, but they are also gently guided to the right path. According to the articles which I have read I can divide authors’ opinions into several main topics such as Kazakh culture teaches children from the beginning to get a good marriage, secondly, it teaches healthy mind, respect elders, Kazakh nation is soft purity of conscience and also some changes in cultural events, traditions and cultures. The first main topic according to Atemova K. the Kazakh culture and its traditions teaches Kazakh nation to have a......

Words: 1056 - Pages: 5

Criticaly Evaluate the Claim That Conscience Is Dictated by Society and Upbringing.

...Critically evaluate the claim that conscience is dictated by society an upbringing. Jean Piaget first postulated the idea that conscience is not the voice of God but a result from our upbringing and what we learn. He was a developmental psychologist who studied the behaviour of children. He theorised that children go through different stages in their understanding of the world around them, and it is not until the age of 10 that young people have a fully developed sense of morality. This scientific approach is very plausible because it is based on observations, and makes predictions that can be tested. For example, you can describe two different situations to a six year old, one of which is someone lying and a minor bad consequence arising, the other is someone accidentally causing a very negative consequence. For a six year old, the latter case would ‘make mummy more cross’ because their understanding is that something is bad because it hurts or upsets people. Ask an older child, and they will accurately say that a parent would be more cross with the child who told a lie. Piaget is showing that conscience is something we learn as we grow and develop. This theory seems to contradict Newman’s ideas. Newman was an intuitionist, believing that conscience is ‘the voice of God’. He believed that when faced with a moral decision, we get a sense of moral direction from God, which we can either listen to or ignore. Conscience is an ability to detect the right course of action. For...

Words: 1359 - Pages: 6

‘Conscience Is the Voice of God’ Discuss.

...‘Conscience is the voice of god’ Discuss. Most people would agree that conscience is the reasoned voice inside us that guides and tells us what we should and shouldn’t do. However peoples views on the origins of conscience can differ a lot; whether people belief its Gods doing or whether it’s innate or even whether it is acquired. In this essay I will be showing the viewpoints of various philosophers with their beliefs on whether conscience is or isn’t the voice of God. Ultimately I believe that conscience is not the voice of God. John Henry Newman believed that conscience was the voice of God, and that following the suggestions of your conscience gives the same significance as to follow God’s laws and values. Newman used conscience as proof for the existence of God. He said that the fact that we feel guilty, even when it is impossible for anyone to know what we have done, for example, having bad thoughts about someone, proves that ‘there is one to whom we are responsible to’. This feeling we have of being accountable was how Newman saw our conscience. He believed that there must be a God that we are accountable to and the reason we feel guilty for wrong thoughts or actions was because we all knew that someone, who Newman believed was God, was looking down on us and we had to impress him in a sense. However there was a flaw to his theory as he didn’t consider people that perhaps don’t ever feel guilty. Also those who don’t believe in God – do they not have a......

Words: 1152 - Pages: 5

Discuss Why Firms Would Choose to Reduce the Price of a Product.

...for why firms would choose to reduce the price of a product and these include, substitution effect, competition, the effect of economic factors and the price elasticity of demand. The substitution effect may make a firm choose to reduce the price of a product because if the price of a substitute good increases, then firms would reduce the price of the good they are selling so that consumers buy their product as the quantity demand for their product is likely to increase. This is so that they gain a maximisation of profits from the products that they sell. For example, if there is a rise in price for coca cola, the substitution effect causes consumers to move away from coca cola and choose Pepsi when the firms reduce the price. Therefore, the quantity demanded for Pepsi increases and the quantity demanded for coca cola decreases. This shows that it is beneficial for firms to reduce prices of a product due to substation effect because they are able to increase their total revenue. Firms would choose to reduce the price of a product due to competition. If the firms’ competitors decided to reduce their prices of their products then the firm would reduce their prices even further for the same products so that the firm gains more consumers as consumers will be looking for firms that offer them the products at the cheapest price. This is because the firm would want more consumers because the more consumers they have the more products they will buy which means that the more sales......

Words: 832 - Pages: 4

‘Assess the View That the Conscience Is Not the Voice of God but Learned’ Discuss.

...To assess this view that the conscience is not the voice of God but learned we have to consider what a conscience really is. Many define the conscience as a personal moral that guides us with moral and ethical issues, helping us to weigh up the more or less important ones. It is also shaped by the consequences from our actions and the lessons we learn. I take the stance of the statement disagreeing with the traditional religious view of a God-given conscience, our conscience is fabricated through our up bringing an environment and the reflection on past memories but the belief in God may affect how we respond and listen to our conscience. The proposition that the concept is not the voice of God but learned is supported by many psychologists. For instance Erich Fromm argued that all humans are influenced by external authorities such as Church leaders, parents and teachers who embed rules and guidelines into us and apply punishments for when with break them. These rules are sub-consciously archived by the individual that forms the basic of our conscience. The disobiendence and failings to follow these rules results in guilt which then leads us to the weakening of our power and more submissive responses to the authority. I see this as a strong, valid argument as we can see it happening in every day life. For example when children misbehave they show signs of guilt and shame. Also many murderers and criminals have had an unstable upbringing with their parents as unsuitable......

Words: 1251 - Pages: 6

Discuss the Claim That Conscience Allows People Too Much Freedom to Behave as They Wish

...Discuss the claim that conscience allows people too much freedom to behave as they wish (35 marks) There is great debate surrounding the idea that the conscience perhaps allows people too much freedom to behave as they wish or whether it is adequate as a guide, of course this debate is dependent on the definition used of conscience, an extremely subjective term. According to the Oxford English Dictionary a conscience is to be defined as ‘an inner feeling or voice viewed as acting as a guide to the rightness or wrongness of one's behaviour’ however this is the view of only some, and there is much debate around the meaning, ability and purpose of the conscience. Theist’s such as St. Thomas Aquinas and Joseph Butler point to God as the source of conscience in contrast to psychologists and sociologists such as Sigmund Freud who point to causes such as authoritative figures shaping our conscience. Equally they disagree on the role it plays, Freud for example suggested it is created as part of the unconscious mind, and believed that it arose as a result of bad experiences early in life, as well as disapproval from parents and society. Butler in contrast would name it ‘’our natural guide’’ given by god to help us act as a moral judge and use reasons to weigh up factors in a moral decision. In this essay I will assess the views of Aquinas, Butler, Fromm, and Freud in relation to the claim and my belief that the conscience does not allow too much freedom. Italian Dominican......

Words: 1466 - Pages: 6