“Benito Cereno” and Manifest Destiny by Allan Moore Emery, Review

In: English and Literature

Submitted By dinamedo
Words 904
Pages 4
In his paper “Benito Cereno” and Manifest Destiny, Allan Moore Emery offers a well-structured and informative presentation of the development of American expansionism, placing Melville’s novella in contemporary political and historical context. More specifically, the paper deals with the concept of Manifest Destiny developed in Benito Cereno, which Emery defines as “the mind-set of those many Americans who fancied themselves citizens of an elect nation, destined by Providence to govern the globe” (49).
In his argument, Emery employs an interesting analogy: San Dominick is a symbol of the Spanish empire. Its “disorderliness” stands for the “anarchy” found by American expansionists in Latin America, while this confusion is attributed to Cereno’s incapability as leader and his weak style of command. Delano’s plot to take control of Cereno’s vessel anticipates American interventionism in the Caribbean, it is argued. However, Manifest Destiny is portrayed in an adverse fashion, considering the fact that the invasion of San Dominick is not motivated by the desire to change the condition of the oppressed, but by mere desire for material gain. The term exceptionalism is not explicitly mentioned, but Emery is clearly hinting at it being the justification for territorial expansion. Manifest Destiny is, as claimed by Emery, a mere rhetorical camouflage for a largely political enterprise (54).
Another interesting political instance, according to the author, is when Delano attempts to buy Babo. Emery calls this attempt “embarrassing”, clearly positioning himself as opposing the doctrine of American exceptionalism. This attempted exchange of goods may be seen as a mission to extend America’s democracy in the Western hemisphere. However, Emery immediately points out that Delano scarcely extends democracy to blacks (55). Delano seems, therefore, as a double agent, both a…...

Similar Documents

Manifest Destiny

...Manifest Destiny Final Draft Manifest Destiny was the 19th century American belief that the United States was destined to expand west on the North American continent. “This was all done in the spirit of Manifest Destiny, a term coined in an 1845 editorial be John L. O’Sullivan.” (Uschan 51) People who had this belief thought God intended for the United States to expand. They thought the country's democratic political system was superior to any others, and therefore should spread across the land. Manifest Destiny was the driving force responsible for changing the face of American history. This philosophy created the nation we have today. The United States doubled in land because of the Louisiana Purchase in 1803. The United States purchased this land from Napoleon for $15 million dollars. Americans enjoyed more land and more opportunities. In this expansion it was discovered that Native Americans had occupied the land. Native Americans were forced to leave their land and travel 800 miles west in search for new land and a new home. About one quarter of the population did not survive the journey. Native Americans died from lack of food or not enough warm clothing for the snow. Slavery was increased because of the expansion of the United States. New farmland was introduced and more work was needed to get done. Manifest Destiny creates cultural and political imperialism. We gained California and New Mexico from the Mexican War because the Guadalupe-Hidalgo treaty ceded a......

Words: 267 - Pages: 2

Manifest Destiny

...Still Found Wanting HST 205-01 Stabler Meaghan Foster April 20th 2009 The Confederacy entered the Civil War with several disadvantages which resulted in the Union predicted a short and easily combated war. Yet despite all their shortcomings the South shocked everyone by turning the Civil War into a four year skirmish resulting in hundreds of thousands of deaths and the destruction of much of the country. Though the Confederacy did hold off the Union for a longer period of time then expected their lack of industry, the confederate army’s tendency to only fight on the offensive combined with the failure of the Confederacy to be recognized as a nation by a foreign power led to the South’s demise. The economies of the North and the South differed drastically during the antebellum period leading up to secession. The South came to be known as a mostly agrarian society based mostly on the work of the farm and plantation. The North became a champion of industrialization, holding most of factories and the work force to man those factories. During the Civil War creation of new supplies became a constant need for both sides of the conflict. The Union found advantage in that the Northern factories produced the majority of the ammunition. Not only did the Union army have the majority of the fire power they also possessed access to more ways of transportation through railroads, ships and wagons. Being able to transport supplies and soldiers over great distances gave the North......

Words: 669 - Pages: 3

Manifest Destiny

...Manifest Destiny was the belief that the United States was destined or endowed by God with the mission of expanding across the continent, from the Atlantic to the Pacific. Many people believed that it was the obvious destiny or America, which was “chosen” by God as a superior nations, to expand, as it is said, “from sea to shining sea.” The phrase was first coined in 1845 by journalist John L. O’Sullivan. He believed that the United States had been given a mission by God to spread democracy, not by force, but simply by spreading across the continent. Obscure at first, the phrase only became popular when Whig Robert Winthrop, who opposed manifest destiny, ridiculed the idea in public. There were many interpretations of manifest destiny, but most reflected the widespread feeling of Nationalism that was sparked by the conclusion of and victory in the War of 1812. The term manifest destiny was widely used and interpreted, but it always seemed to outline three basic themes. Those themes were virtue, mission, and destiny. Manifest destiny focused on virtue of America’s people and government. American Exceptionalism was the belief that America’s history was above the norm and uncommonly “good”. Exceptionalism showed in the beliefs of people who thought that God had selected America as a “City on a Hill”; a role model and an ideal for the rest of the world, especially still-developing areas. Also, many people believed that America’s people, the “Anglo-Saxon race” were, in terms......

Words: 1000 - Pages: 4

Manifest Destiny and Sectional Conflict

...Manifest destiny was a belief that was popular in the nineteenth century that said that the expansion of the United States throughout America was not only justified, but inevitable. People’s belief in manifest destiny actually greatly impacted the sectional conflict over slavery by causing even greater conflict. As the United States expanded and acquired new states, the South wanted to have slavery in the new territories, as well as keeping it intact in the South. In contrast, most Northerners were in favor of completely abolishing slavery while others liked the idea of keeping slavery in the South, but stopping it from expanding to the new territories. Tension rose between the North and the South because of manifest destiny. In 1820, the Missouri Compromise was passed because of the conflict in Congress and the U.S. government. It prohibited slavery in the Louisiana Territory except within the boundaries of the new state of Missouri. This solved matters for a little while, but the question was raised again in 1850 after the Mexican-American War regarding the status of the territories acquired during the war. The Compromise of 1850 defused that tension and avoided secession or civil war and reduced sectional conflict for four years. In 1854, the Kansas-Nebraska Act created the territories of Kansas and Nebraska which opened new land for settlement. The same problems arose again but this time, they were solved through popular sovereignty. The Kansas-Nebraska Act allowed the......

Words: 303 - Pages: 2

Benito Cereno and American Characteristic

...Rutgers University 19th Century Literature Prof. Bland Typical American Character “Benito Cereno” is a work that exceedingly depicts how ideological self-delusion of an American character is one of the most dangerous capacities of mankind. Captain Delano a Yankee from “Duxbury Massachusetts” exemplifies these two American cultures of concerning nature and confidence. As Americans we have concerned and helped other less fortunate (i.e. the amount we donate to help third world countries), we are also confident and fearless in nature that we can accomplish anything (i.e. American dream). These traditional American characteristics I believe forms the American arrogance that we are stereotyped to have. We maybe helping others we have no business helping. Just like the American culture Delano truly believes he is doing the right thing, by showing concern and having confidence in being able to help the San Dominick slave-ship and he is incapable of seeing the horrifying consequences of his actions both with respect to his “friendly racism” and his fantasy of “superiority”. He spends a day on the San Dominick following a slave mutiny, never quite aware that anything is wrong until the truth all but bites his head off. Delano subscribes to a typical "Northern" view of African slaves: he considers them to be naturally good-natured, submissive servants. He spends much of his time aboard the San Dominick condescendingly admiring Babo's performance. Melville critiques this naiveté......

Words: 1844 - Pages: 8

Benito Mussolini

...------------------------------------------------- Plan: * 1 Scurtă trecere în revistă a dictaturii lui Benito Mussolini * 2 Biografie timpurie * 3 Conflicte cu Mișcarea Socialistă Italiană și anii primului Război Mondial * 4 Dictatorul Fascist Mussolini, "Il Duce" * 5 Intervențiile armate în Etiopia, Spania * 6 Al Doilea Război Mondial * 7 Moartea lui Benito Mussolini ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- Benito Mussolini ------------------------------------------------- Benito Mussolini | | Benito Amilcare Andrea Mussolini (n. 29......

Words: 1636 - Pages: 7

Michael Moore

...Review Bowling for Columbine: -by Kasper Jørgensen Rating: Michael Moore’s documentary “Bowling for Columbine” is inspired by the school massacre at Columbine High School back in 1999. The film explores what Michael Moore suggests could be the reasons behind such a tragedy. An early scene of the movie shows how Michael Moore gets his hands on a hunting rifle, simply by opening a bank account (!) Just before leaving the bank, Moore asks, "Don’t you think it's a little dangerous handing out guns at a bank?" A clear indication of his point of view, so early in the documentary. Michael Moore uses several effects to affect us, the whole setup of the movie is so messy and cleverly cut, that you have to be a true-blood American and blissfully unaware about things around you, not to feel that he has a point with this documentary. He uses the shock effect many times, best illustrated by the video montage of some of the awful American foreign policy decisions. Along with this montage of video footage, the song: What a Wonderful World” by Louis Armstrong is playing, which of course is ironic as hell. His strongest argument for all the gun violence in the U.S.A. is the fear that gets thrown at the Americans, throughout their entire lives, all broadcasted by the media. He also shows the American history, through a hilarious animated movie, with a bullet as the narrator. All in all, if you want a good laugh, try to understand other countries mentality or just want some......

Words: 280 - Pages: 2

Dollar Diplomacy and Manifest Destiny

...Dollar Diplomacy and Manifest Destiny The founders of the United States had an idea. Yes, they thought we should be an independent country. Yes, they thought Great Britain and the King were on the wrong side of history. And yes, they thought we could prove democracy worked. However, they had much bigger plans. There was an idea that our system of government was so good that, in fact, it was our job to spread it like a wildfire. They believed we had a right to control the Americas through the Monroe Doctrine, which was only strengthened by the Roosevelt Corollary. We were meant to expand, to showcase our ideals, and to prove that no matter the size, no matter the wealth, democracy worked. We used brute strength, moral values, and monetary influence to accomplish our goals. In William Taft’s 1912 State of the Union address, he specifically talks about the effects of Dollar Diplomacy. Taft is a perfect example of how the United States was able to bury its competition and rebels through means that aren’t traditionally looked at when talking about the ideas of our founders. Before diving in to the speech, this idea of expansion has to be fleshed out. It’s called “Manifest Destiny,” and it is our most important foreign policy. Scholars argue about when the term was officially coined, but no one argues that the ideas were there before there was a word. Thomas Jefferson wrote a letter to his successor, James Madison, about his vision for the American empire. He says, “we......

Words: 1174 - Pages: 5

The Age of Manifest Destiny Is, at Its Heart, an Age of Expansion--or Rather, an Age of Many Expansions. Examine the Interplay of Three of These Expansions: the Expansion of Slavery, the Expansion of the Market Economy,

...U. S. History I: 1607-1865 | | | | Question Answers Question 1 The age of Manifest Destiny is, at its heart, an age of expansion--or rather, an age of many expansions. Examine the interplay of three of these expansions: the expansion of slavery, the expansion of the market economy, and geographic expansion of the nation. How did these three expansions reinforce and feed off of each other? How did they bring the nation to what William Henry Seward referred to as the brink of an "Irrepressible Conflict" by 1858? Answer As America was growing, at a vast rate that might have been one of the side effects of expansion and it looking forward for room to expand. American believed that it was their God given choice or right to occupy others area. It was getting more common about to expanding widely than they captured many states and made them slave. It was believed that the expansion of slavery was the result of popular sovereignty. As the expansion of territories took place, slavery expanded a long with it. The expansion of slavery would not have been resolved until and unless some crises arose. However, the two options that were to be considered were either to extend slavery to all as the territories expanded or to end it completely. There was not concept of practicing slavery in one territory and not in the other. It had to be practiced uniformly in all territories. Slavery was not the problem then they gradually grew to be, although there were some rumblings......

Words: 654 - Pages: 3


...tober 27th, 2014 - Destiny: Guardian Dawn, the official adaptation of the video game is set to hit book stores everywhere next month, according to publisher Macmillan Press. The novel, penned by Karen Traviss, veteran author of numerous Halo, Gears of War, and Star Wars tie-in novels, closely follows the sweeping narrative and richly detailed story of the video game. Here's the official plot synopsis, provided by Macmillan: Centuries of invasions by aliens have ravaged Earth's solar system and humanity is confined to a single city on Earth. A lone Guardian, dead for centuries, is awoken after centuries of being dead, by a Ghost. No, the Ghost isn't dead a dead person too, it's just a nickname for a flying machine. It's a different Ghost than the one in Halo, because that one's a vehicle. This Ghost is kind of like a flying robot AI. Yeah, sort of like that Guilty Spark thing. Anyway, a darkness is brewing, a darkness so evil that the lone Guardian is really the only one in the entire history of the universe who can stand against it. After narrowly escaping from some aliens, the lone Guardian flies to the tower, sacred headquarters of the Guardians, where he or she encounters dozens of other lone Guardians, each one sharing an uncannily similar story of being awoken after centuries of being dead by a Ghost, and narrowly escaping aliens to fly to the tower. The lone Guardians venture out into harrowing battles on Earth, Mars, the Moon, and Venus, encountering deadly......

Words: 409 - Pages: 2

Manifest Destiny

...Ryan Barker Professor Todd Leahy History 110 22 Nov 2014 Manifest Destiny John L. O’Sullivan’s vision of Manifest Destiny seems almost to be an interpretation of god’s will in his propaganda of why we should take more land and expand the United States. The negative tone that is conveyed on Mexico is flagrantly abundant as he states that Texas is already in the occupation of the United States and we should clear away any remnants of Spain. He states that the territories are sparsely populated and are of more use to a country that will have more than 250 million residents in the future. He leads on to say that California is also freely available as it is being settled by Americans. Slavery is pointed out to not be an issue in this, but racial undertones line the entire 3 pages. He refers to “Anglo Saxon” or white people as those who are destine to take the rest of this continent and even slurs the French in Canada stating that they can be attacked as well. From the words used in this paper O’Sullivan was not intending to spark a cohabitation with Mexican and African Americans in these new states. The overall purpose of this piece in my opinion is to stir the expansionist feelings inside of Americans to start an empire and further the United States power through violent means. It seemed to be a way to light a fire in the white puritans hearts that they are better than the rest of the world and should spread and multiply because of this. This is obviously a very......

Words: 298 - Pages: 2

Allan Poe

...never really knew his parents. His father vanished from the family early in his life and his mother died when he was the age of 3. Parted ways from his relatives Poe went on to live with Frances and John Allan. John Allan was a successful tobacco seller and the lived in Richmond, Virginia. He formed a great bond with Ms. Allan but never understood John Allan. John Allan also had problems funding Edgar’s education at the University of Virginia in 1826 so in order to make ends meet Poe would gamble the difference, with that option turning on him he went into debt. Around the time of Poe joining the army he published his first book, Tamerlane and Other Poems in 1827. He won a spot in 1830 to West Point which was a military academy. Although he excelled at his studies at West Point he was dismissed only after a year of joining because of his poor handling of duties. Some folks say he wanted to be court-martialed. When Poe left the academy he focused on writing full time. He moved frequently living in cities like Baltimore, New York City, Philadelphia and Richmond. In the early 1830’s he stayed with his aunt in Baltimore. In 1835 Poe returned to Richmond where he went to work for Southern Literary Messenger a magazine company. He was called a cut-throat critic for his vicious reviews on his contemporaries, He also published some of his own works in this magazine company this included two parts of the only novel he has The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym. He held that job shortly......

Words: 710 - Pages: 3

Manifest Destiny

...Tammy Prater Survey of American History I HIST 2010 Spring 2014 “Manifest Destiny and American Territorial Expansion A Brief History with Documents” By Carrie Duncan Manifest Destiny is an event, and a philosophy, that changed how the United States expanded from thirteen colonies into what it is today. The term, Manifest Destiny, was first used in 1845 by John O'Sullivan, to give explanation for the United States' right of expansion. He stated that"...the right of our manifest destiny to over spread and to possess the whole of the continent which Providence has given us for the development of the great experiment of liberty and federaltive development of self government entrusted to us. It is right such as that of the tree to the space of air and the earth suitable for the full expansion of its principle and destiny of growth." 1 The principle behind Manifest Destiny has been around since Christopher Columbus first discovered the Caribbean. Many years after Columbus' discovery of the New World, Europe and Mexico were wanting to expand, and control new territories in North America. This want for new territory, would cause boundary issues and fears to arise soon after the Revolutionary War with the fledgling government of the United States. These boundary issues and fears would help the supporters, who wanted to expand the United States borders, to push for acquiring new territories......

Words: 2589 - Pages: 11

Manifest Destiny

...Juvenile Delinquency Chapter Two - Assignment Three Scenario A Question1 The situation that Shatiek finds himself in is a sad and unfortunate one. However, as a juvenile judge I would treat him as a minor. Having considered all the available evidence and information, it is clear that the young man has been influenced by the society. Crime and drugs are all he knows about. The young man has never had the opportunity in his short life to try and be anybody else other than that. The courts should provide the young man with this opportunity. I would place him in a youth facility for a prolonged stay to help him. Question 2 A 16-year-old like Shatiek may or may not deserve a second chance. It is determined by the evidence and information adduced in court concerning the particular young 16 old. Question 3 Shatieks's behavior is very much common among adolescent boys especially in the low-end areas and estates. Young boys are introduced very early in their lives into crime, drugs and firearms. Scenario B Question 1 The children should be prosecuted in a juvenile court. They should be locked up in a youth facility for a period. The service would allow them realize the seriousness of their actions. It would arrest this deviant behavior before is spills out of control. Question 2 There is sufficient evidence to justify crimes among the participants of the sex ring. Whatever missing evidence or piece of information there is can easily be investigated by......

Words: 991 - Pages: 4


...Shayna Mayoh October 8, 2012 Tooele Eng. 1010 Essay #1 Destiny Destiny: the events that will necessarily happen to a particular person in the future. When a child is born is that child already destined to be like his/her parents? When our parents, siblings, or friends make mistakes do we learn from them? Do we change ourselves to be better because of the things in life that go on? Can we in a way choose our own destiny or does fate decide for us? In “I Stand Here Ironing” by Tillie Olsen, the daughter was born with a disability/illness. The mother did nothing to make her have this illness. The daughter was going to have it when she was born no matter what the mother did. The mother did not have this illness, so in this way she was not fated to be like her mom. Although this doesn’t mean the daughter was completely different then the mother, she could have acted the same maybe had the same personality as her mother. The personality that a child is born with is not necessarily going to be there personality for the rest of their life. As you grow older you change and is changes with you. When you meet new people you sometimes want to be like them so you will change your way of doing things to be like them, where at other times you meet people you don’t want to be like so you do everything you can not to be like them. Do the people we love most make mistakes, even if we don’t realize it at the time it happens? When they do, do we look back and try to make......

Words: 475 - Pages: 2