Argument Mapping

In: Business and Management

Submitted By lilredsptfire
Words 1183
Pages 5
Argument Maps for 55-mph and Balkan Conflict Abstract
This paper covers two arguments by the usage of simple and complex argument maps. The first argument is on reducing the national speed limit to 55 mph and the second looks at the conflict in the Balkans and the debate of U.S. intervention.

Argument Maps for 55-mph and Balkan Conflict
There are numerous reasons to argue for and even against the 55 mph speed limit, as well as the question as to if the U.S. should or should not intervene in the Balkan conflict. This paper and its attached argument maps are designed to look at each of these arguments from both sides and make an informed decision concerning the matters. First, it will examine the claim “The U.S. should return to the 55- mph speed limit in order to conserve fuel and save lives.” Second it will examine the claim of “The conflict in Bosnia is somebody else’s trouble. The U.S. should not intervene militarily.” In either argument, there are pros and cons which much be addressed in order to make informed decisions concerning if policy makers should agree or disagree with either premise.
The U.S. Should Return to the 55- mph Speed Limit The argument continues again today as to if the United States should return to the 55mph speed limit. Higher gas prices have forced some American drivers to trade in their S.U.V.’s for smaller, more fuel-efficient cars; combine errands in an effort to drive less; or even add air to their tires to eke out a few more miles per gallon. Since 1975 when the U.S. government did lower the speed limit to a mandatory 55mph on major highways and then repealed the law in 1995, many have long believed that this is again a solution to the problem of highway deaths and conserve already high priced and dwindling fuel supplies (Moore, 1999).
In the simple argument map in figure…...

Similar Documents

Mapping an Argument

...Mapping an Argument Steven Montesano CRT/205 11/17/12 Ann Armstrong The first article chosen was Abortion Is a Form of Genocide by Meredith Eugene Hunt. The issue in this article is “abortion as a form of genocide is accurate by historical and accepted standards of the word’s definition” (Abortion, 2010). I highlighted this as the issue because it includes everything the author is trying to prove to the reader. Hunt wants to make it known that she believes abortion is a form of genocide even though the parameters fit loosely. She also points to the fact that history has shown evidence of genocide, and she uses that history to show the similarities between genocide and abortion. Hunt is making an argument that is both deductive and inductive. In some cases she gives proof in her accusations of the terms abortion and genocide. On the other hand, at times she offers supporting information intended to sway the reader to her side of the argument. The first conclusion in the article is “abortion does not fit in perfectly with the original use” with the premise being “Hunt identifies the origin of the term “genocide” (Abortion, 2010). This is a valid deductive argument because the term genocide is factual and therefore abortion not fitting exactly into that definition can only be true. The next conclusion found was “abortion could have genocidal characteristics, but would not qualify as genocide legally”, and the premise is “unwanted preborn children as a group......

Words: 870 - Pages: 4

Mapping an Argument

...Mapping an Argument Kimberly Williams CRT/205 11/11/2012 University of Phoenix Mapping an Argument What is the Issue? I have decided to read about the Traditional newspapers are becoming extinct. The issue with this is the cost of the newspapers going up and how the Internet is taking over the place of the newspaper. People are now depending on the Internet for their sources instead of the newspapers. The competition-deflecting effects of printing cost got destroyed by the Internet. The newspaper people often note that newspapers benefit society as a whole, but it is getting so expensive to keep newspapers running. The imperatives to strengthen journalism and to strengthen newspapers have been so tightly wound as to be indistinguishable. They are trying to find ways to strengthen the ways of newspapers. "Save newspapers" to "save society" is the big issue of this article. The other issue is to keep the newspapers from becoming extinct. The other article that I read about was the Veterans Administration health care not being readily available in rural areas. The issues of this article were the increased efforts to improve the care that is available for rural veterans. Also anther issue for the veterans was the long distances it is a huge problem for most of them. Long distances and restrictive rules have become an issue for the veterans and they have also become very obstacles to health care for many of them. Rural veterans have other problems with this also. The......

Words: 1277 - Pages: 6

Competency Mapping

...Competency Mapping Introduction A lot is going on in recent times on the issue of competency mapping. A lot of resource is spent and consultants are invited to do competency mapping. Competency mapping is gaining much more importance and organizations are aware of having good human resources or putting the right people on right job. Competency mapping is important and is an essential exercise. Every well managed firm should have well defined roles and list of competencies required to perform each role effectively. Such list should be used for recruitment, performance management, promotions, placements and training needs identification. In performing or carrying out work, it is essential that the required job skills first be articulated. This information not only helps to identify individuals who have the matching skills for doing the work but also the skills that will enhance the successful performance of the work. Yet often to perform well, it is not enough just to have these skills. It is also critical to complement the skills with the necessary knowledge and attitudes. For e.g. the necessary knowledge will enable an individual to apply the right skills for any work situation that will arise while having the right attitude will motivate him to give his best efforts. These skills, knowledge and attitudes required for the work are usually collectively referred as competencies. What is Competency? Competency is an underlying characteristic required to perform......

Words: 1055 - Pages: 5

Argument Mapping

...In this case the qualifier is certainly and as we move from a simple, static, uncontested argument to a complex, dynamic and contested argument once can see that the qualifier stance does not change. For instance, consumer Reports tested the effect of higher speeds on gas mileage. David Champion, director of auto testing, found that boosting the highway speed of a 2006 Toyota Camry cut gasoline mileage dramatically: •55 m.p.h. – 40.3 miles per gallon •65 m.p.h. – 34.9 miles per gallon •75 m.p.h. – 29.8 miles per gallon On a hypothetical 1,900-mile round trip from New York City to Disney World in Florida, the Camry would use 47 gallons of gas at 55 m.p.h.. But at 75 mph, it would burn nearly 64 gallons – a $70 difference. If everyone could reduce their driving by just 10 percent, the savings would total nearly 1 million barrels of gasoline every day. (Retting, 2008) In regards to the fatalities, Institute studies show that deaths on rural interstates increased 25-30 percent when states began increasing speed limits from 55 to 65 mph in 1987. A 2002 study also evaluated the effects of increasing rural interstate speed limits from 65 mph to either 70 or 75 mph. States that increased speed limits to 75 mph experienced 38 percent more deaths per million vehicle miles traveled than expected; an estimated 780 more deaths. States that increased speed limits to 70 mph experienced a 35 percent increase, resulting in approximately 1,100 more deaths. As one can see maintaining the......

Words: 946 - Pages: 4

Mapping and Argument

...Mapping and Argument The issue on the article “How safe is America really?” discusses the problems we have with safety on American soil and different parts of the world. It talks about the recent terror attack in Boston as well as 9/11 and how since then Americans do not feel as safe as they use to in their homeland. It also discusses what the government is trying to do to keep this country safe from terrorist from different parts of the world, and ways they can try to stop the next big plot before it actually happens. I believe the unstated premises of this article is that terrorist attacks are becoming more common since 9/11, and that people seem to be more on edge because they do not know when the next attack will come in to this country. Though Americans stay strong and keep moving on with their lives they still fear the unknown safety of being a part of big events, like the Boston Marathon. The stated premises is that the government is trying to stop the next terrorist attack before it starts, they are working with intelligence agencies from many countries and gathering names of people with ties to the Al-Qaeda and making sure that they do not try to attack our country. In conclusion our President Obama is trying to keep us as safe as possible, whether physically or mentally he is trying to protect us from possible trauma in our lives and I feel as though he believes we are a strong country and no one is going to take our spirit away. I feel as though despite......

Words: 586 - Pages: 3

Mapping an Argument

...Mapping an Argument Karla Cooper CRT/205 September 15, 2013 Laura Mellott Mapping an Argument Article #1 Gun Control The article’s issue was about gun control in the United States and how the constitution should be challenged on this controversial topic. Discussions about citizens’ rights to bear arms extend back to ancient times. Supporters of gun control would like even tighter restrictions on the sale and circulation of firearms. According to Samuel Adams he argued that the Constitution should never be interpreted “to prevent the people of the United States who are peaceable citizens from keeping their own arms.” Several stated premises in the article were that “Opponents of gun control interpret the Second Amendment as the guarantee of a personal right to keep and bear arms.” In two other rulings, the Supreme Court reaffirmed this view in upholding New Jersey’s tough gun control law in 1969 (Burton v. Sills) and in supporting the federal ban on possession of firearms by felons in 1980 (Lewis v. United States). Gun control laws have several functions. They may be designed to hinder certain people from gaining access to any firearms. The laws may limit possession of certain types of weapons to the police and the military. A person who wants to make a gun purchase or obtain a gun license may be subject to a waiting period. Gun-control laws vary from country to country. The following stated premises are that gun violence also......

Words: 912 - Pages: 4

Conformal Mapping

...SOME PROBLEMS IN CONFORMAL MAPPING D. C. SPENCER 1. Introduction. Attention will be confined to a group of problems centering around so-called schlicht functions—that is, functions regular in a given domain and assuming no value there more than once. The type of problem we consider involves determination of precise bounds for certain quantities depending on the function/, as ƒ ranges over the schlicht functions in question. Since, for suitable normalization of the functions at some fixed point of the domain, the resulting family of functions is compact or normal, the extremal schlicht functions always exist and the problem is to characterize them. Interest was focused on this category of questions by the work of Koebe in the years 1907-1909, who established for the family of funct i o n s / o f the form ƒ(z) = z+a2Z2+aszz+ • • • , schlicht and regular in \z\ < 1 , a series of properties, among them the theorem of distortion bearing Koebe's name. This theorem asserts the existence of bounds for the absolute value of the derivative ƒ'(s), these bounds depending only on \z\. Further efforts were directed toward finding the precise values of the bounds asserted by Koebe's theorem, but success was not attained until 1916 when Bieberbach, Faber, Pick and others gave a final form to the theorem of distortion. At the same time the precise bound for | a2\ was given, namely 2, and the now famous conjecture was made that \an\ ^n for every n. Since 1916 this group of problems has......

Words: 3481 - Pages: 14

Mapping an Argument

...allowing those of the same sex to get married we’re being unfair and allowing conservative republicans to force their own beliefs upon us and make us accept them. Last but not least the author touches on how in more recent history articles such as Proposition 8 have been passed by the government to prevent same sex marriage (in California). There were several stated premises in this article. One was that gay marriage shouldn’t be allowed because it violates the institution of marriage. Another was that there is no constitutional basis for banning gay marriage, which there is not. Other premises in this article included not exposing children to same sex relationships and how religious views play a part in the argument against gay marriage. “ The whole argument really comes down to letting consenting adults do as they wish, provided they are not hurting anybody, and keeping our beliefs out of the lives of others, just as we expect for ourselves. A homosexual getting married really has no effect on anybody but themselves. Although with all the extra weddings, gifts, and honeymoons, it would actually be a good way to stimulate the economy! (J. Kellard, 2012)” I’ve never understood why people persecute others just because they are different. It makes no sense that we discriminate against those in same sex relationships by not allowing them to get married. People protest and demand that these people aren’t afforded the same rights as them and to me that isn’t fair. How......

Words: 725 - Pages: 3

Arugment Mapping

...Argument mapping by Michael A Stevenson pad 520 public policy 4/25/2014 Abstract This paper covers two arguments by the usage of simple and complex argument maps. The first argument is on reducing the national speed limit to 55 mph and the second looks at the conflict in the Balkans and the debate of U.S. intervention. Argument Maps for 55-mph and Balkan Conflict There are numerous reasons to argue for and even against the 55 mph speed limit, as well as the question as to if the U.S. should or should not intervene in the Balkan conflict. This paper and its attached argument maps are designed to look at each of these arguments from both sides and make an informed decision concerning the matters. First, it will examine the claim “The U.S. should return to the 55- mph speed limit in order to conserve fuel and save lives.” Second it will examine the claim of “The conflict in Bosnia is somebody else’s trouble. The U.S. should not intervene militarily.” In either argument, there are pros and cons which much be addressed in order to make informed decisions concerning if policy makers should agree or disagree with either premise. The U.S. Should Return to the 55- mph Speed Limit The argument continues again today as to if the United States should return to the 55mph speed limit. Higher gas prices have forced some American drivers to trade in their S.U.V.’s for smaller, more fuel-efficient cars; combine errands in an effort to drive less; or even add air to their tires to......

Words: 1187 - Pages: 5

It and Geo-Mapping

...1) The key software application used by the Tea Collection company The software used by the company are: • A website on which customers can shop online • Design software to create the patterns, prints, and the clothes in general. • A geographic data map software: to target new selling areas. Based on geo-mapping, the software selects the zones that are not saturated with children clothing stores, and correspond to the demographic and social characteristics of the brand. It is then possible to narrow where to implant new stores. • A website especially for retailers to place orders over directly on the Internet. 2) How does geo-mapping software help the company grow? Explain how sales representatives use the results of the geo-mapping system. In the case of Tea Collection, we have seen that geo-mapping software helped the company to target new selling area, by sorting zones by level of activity, saturation rate of children clothes and demographic specificities. Geo-Mapping is one of the most popular data representation techniques as it allows companies analyse an area without spending too much money having to travel to that location and carrying out surveys wasting precious time and money. Geospatial analysis captures, stores, manipulates, analyses and presents all types of spatial or geographical data, using spatio-temporal information, according to what the user is looking for. The data representation is quite interactive, where the user can define......

Words: 317 - Pages: 2

Competency Mapping

...COMPETENCY MAPPING A competency is an underlying characteristic of an individual which enables him/her to deliver superior performance in a given situation. Competencies consist of clusters of knowledge, attitude and skill set. Competency mapping is the assessment of employee skill set as an individual and as part of a team. Competency mapping is a process of identifying key competencies for a particular position in an organization, and then using it for job-evaluation, recruitment, training and development, performance management, succession planning, etc. Competency mapping is about identifying behaviors and personal skills which distinguish excellent and outstanding performance from the average. It also involves identifying key competencies required by a team at a lower level and by the organization as a whole to achieve desired results. Competency mapping generally involves examining two areas i.e. emotional intelligence and other individual strengths like decision making, team work, performing under pressure etc. Steps in Competency mapping 1) Role Competencies To start at the basic level we need to understand and define role and role competencies mean a set of competencies required to perform a given role, each competency further has a skill set. a)  Identification of Role Competencies i) Structure & list of roles. ii) Definition of roles. iii) Job description. iv) Competency requirement. b) Structure and List Roles: i) Organizational structure study and......

Words: 539 - Pages: 3

Mapping

...Prof. Arthur Archer 01/13/12 Mapping The author’s definition of mapping goes far and beyond the basic definition of the word. From the first sentence of his paper, James Corner sets up the reader and accurately introduces his intentions of redefining what mapping is; “Mapping is a fantastic cultural project, creating and building the world as much as measuring and describing it.” The introductory paragraph mentions the “agency” of mapping. It is not until later in the reading that one begins to understand what is meant by the “agency”. The intentions become clearer once we define the term agency. The dictionary Merriam-Webster defines the operation as “the capacity, condition, or state of acting or of exerting power” and in an instrumentality sense: “a person or thing through which power is exerted or an end is achieved”. So as Mr. Corner later describes maps have an immense power over us, of how we view the world, what things are important to us, and in turn the maps we create have the power to guide us in certain direction, or from a certain point of view. At times Corner speaks about agency of mapping as if he feels that it should become a field of study as a whole, because of all the different elements that it envelopes; the study of natural processes and historical context to name a few. That the creation of a map should not be simply to record or trace. A map is a collection of data that represents information gathered during mapping. According to Corner a map is......

Words: 1667 - Pages: 7

Mapping

...Mapping Matrix from - CHC50908 Diploma of Children's Services (early childhood education and care) to - CHC50113 Diploma of Early Childhood Education and Care This mapping tool only includes additional training and assessment requirements for each unit. Changes to wording or additional words are highlighted in bold type Unit of competency: CHCECE023 Analyse information to inform learning SupersedesCHCPR509A - Gather, interpret and use information about children Elements of Competency/Performance Criteria 1. Gather and document information about children Changes Gaps to address in transition 1.1 Undertake observations and gather detailed information about children’s learning, using a wide range of approaches Changed wording 1.2 Ensure the assessment methods and tools used to gather information consider assessment principles New criteria 1.3 Gather information and observations over time and in a variety of spaces 1.4 Include the voices of educators, children, peers, families and other professionals where appropriate 2. Monitor children’s learning & development Changed wording New criteria 2.1 Use information and observations to analyse and monitor children’s strengths, interests, relationships and learning in conjunction with the approved framework’s learning outcomes New criteria 2.2 Identify children who may need additional support in order to achieve particular learning outcomes New criteria 2.3 Use......

Words: 744 - Pages: 3

Mapping

... Sheryl Smith Argument Mapping PAD 520 Dr. Glenn Starks October 26, 2015 Create an argument map based on the influence diagram presented in Case 1.3 and complete all the criteria provided in the exercise, beginning with claim. Claim: “The U.S. should return to the 55-mph speed limit in order to conserve fuel and save lives. Information: Authorities consider reducing highway speed from 70-mph to 60-mph could reduce gasoline consumption between 2% and 3%. Which would explain the price reduction at least by 10%. With today’s prices at 38 cent a gallon. However, a lower speed limit saves approximately 167,000 barrels of oil per day and would save approximately 6,400 lives a year.” (Dunn, William N. (2012), Para. 3. P. 24). Warrant 1: While reducing the speed limit can increase the fuel efficiency on the vehicles. Backing: Some cars are already made with fuel injection while driven between 30-mph and 60-mph. Mileage will drop noticeably if driven over 65 mph. Slowing down would reduce the amount of gasoline used as well as limitation grants. On a central standpoint these changes will cost less. Warrant 2: Reduced speed limit will also decrease the loss to of aid due to increasing gasoline prices. Backing 2: Reduce the number of victim will also reduce the governments cost of medical care. Objections: Shortening the speed will rise travel time as well as leading to traffic jams on major highways. Claim: “The U.S. should return to the 55-mph speed limit in order to......

Words: 1690 - Pages: 7

Mapping

...ARUGMENT MAPPING Week three assignment #1 Lionel Gantt Dr. Andre Lee PAD-520 Strayer University 04/25/2016 Create an argument map based on the influence diagram presented in Case 1.3 and complete all the criteria provided in the exercise, beginning with this claim: “The U.S. should return to the 55- mph speed limit in order to conserve fuel and save lives. Make a contention map taking into account the impact chart exhibited in Case 1.3 and finish every one of the criteria gave in the activity, starting with this claim: "The U.S. should come back to the 55-mph speed limit so as to moderate fuel and spare lives." "The law was a reaction to the 1973 oil ban, and its plan was to decrease fuel utilization. In the year after the National Maximum Speed Law was sanctioned, street fatalities declined 16.4%, from 54052 in 1973 to 45196 in 1974" (eric.ed.gov). In 1974, the government passed the National Maximum Speed Law, which confined the most extreme allowable vehicle speed farthest point to 55 miles for each hour (mph) on every single interstate street in the United States. As indicated by the Environmental Protection Agency, "you can accept that every 5 mph you drive more than 50 mph resemble paying an extra $0.25 per gallon for gas, in extra; driving every vehicle achieves its ideal efficiency at an alternate velocity; gas mileage for the most part reductions quickly at paces above 50 mph"(colostate.edu). Forceful heading to incudes; speeding, quick increasing speed......

Words: 904 - Pages: 4