Applying Critical Thinking

In: Business and Management

Submitted By peds9975
Words 3933
Pages 16
Applying Critical Thinking: Analyzing Memo from FSEU Director of Human Resources to President, FSEU Local No. 343

Abstract
The Illinois State intends to privatize the Department of Transportation (DoT) information systems management function. This function is currently being performed by 75 State employees, 43 of whom are members of Federated State Employee Union (FSEU) Local 343. On May 12, 2010 the Governor of Illinois notified the President of FSEU Local 343 about the State’s intent. The President of FSEU has asked the union members if the union should oppose the outsourcing proposal. On June 5, 2010 the FSEU Director of Human Resources responded to the President of FSEU Local 343 with the union member’s discussion and recommended opposing the outsourcing proposal.
The paper uses the methodology from the book “Asking the Right Questions – A Guide to Critical Thinking” by M. Neil Bowne and Stuart M. Keeley, to analyze the memo from FSEU Director of Human Resources to the President, FSEU Local No. 343.

Introduction
The Illinois State intends to privatize the Department of Transportation (DoT) information systems management function. The Governor of Illinois notified Mr. Cesar Padilla, the President of Federated State Employee Union (FSEU) Local 343 about the State’s intent on May 12, 2010. The President of FSEU has asked the union members if the union should oppose the outsourcing proposal. In response to the request from the President of FSEU Local No. 343, Ms. Barbara Glenn, the Director of Human Resources FSEU responded with the union’s recommendation in a memo. Appendix A shows a complete response memo from the Director of Human Resources FSEU.
The response from the Director of Human Resources FSEU, the author, is analyzed using critical thinking methodologies from the book “Asking the Right Questions – A Guide to Critical Thinking” by M. Neil…...

Similar Documents

Applying Critical Thinking Skills to Organizational Issues

...other companies are surviving because they retained proper control of their pay budget while the compensation committee at PDQ approved each annually increasing raise for the CEO. The author assumedly lost a lot of respect for his company and may feel as though his position is threatened due to this large failure amongst PDQ, losing the value of security for his occupation. Both the value conflict and value assumption found here lead to the same conclusion of replacing the CEO with someone new. Descriptive Assumptions Fallacies in Reasoning Quality of Evidence Rival Causes Deceptive Statistics Omitted Information Reasonable Conclusions References Browne, M. N., & Keeley, S.M. (2007). Asking the right questions: A guide to critical thinking, 8th edition. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson/Prentice Hall...

Words: 1192 - Pages: 5

Critical Thinking

...essay involving critical thinking and an essay that shows no critical thinking. Essay involving critical thinking is the balanced one while an essay that shows no critical thinking might be taking a particular side of the aspect. First one addresses all/optimum dimensions of the issue while the later one might focus on few or any particular dimensions. First one is normally not biased but the later one is often biased. First one gives a true picture of the issue while the second one might give the improper/incomplete/manipulated one. How does critical thinking impact on how you read an academic article in your course? Applying critical thinking in reading academic article makes the reading article more effective because I do not blindly believe in anything. Rather, I look for the evidences/justifications of any logics/claims. I can differentiate between opinion and logic backed up by valid evidence with the help of critical thinking. Moreover, thinking about the logics, claims and evidences by the other/different side/dimension gives me more insight about what I am reading. In conclusion, applying critical thinking in reading an academic article can give me a detail picture of the article, so that I can assess the degree of quality/reliability of the article. How would critical thinking impact your advice letter to a client when you are working in the accounting profession? When I am working in the accounting profession, applying critical thinking in my advice......

Words: 333 - Pages: 2

Critical Thinking

...Critical Thinking as defined by the National Council for Excellence in Critical Thinking: “The intellectually disciplined process of actively and skillfully conceptualizing, applying, analyzing, synthesizing, and/or evaluating information gathered from, or generated by, observation, experience, reflection, reasoning, or communication, as a guide to belief and action.” (Scriven & Paul, 1987). A generalization of critical thinking is taking a step back and performing the most reasonable action after analyzing every possible solution. Critical Thinking can be broken down into three phases: Discipline- the ability to stop action; Conceptualize- gather information; and Decision- take the appropriate action. Phase one in critical thinking, Discipline, is the ability to stop from making a decisive action without critical forethought. Everyone does not have the discipline to stop and think of the repercussion of his or her immediate action. Phase two is Conceptualization, which is the gathering of information and analyzing all possible solutions. For example during phase two, a person will perform analysis of the immediate situation, observation of the surrounding, and will visualize all viable solutions prior to committing to an action. The final phase is the action phase, taking the appropriate action decided upon. To further elaborate the three phases of critical thinking, I will break down the example in an Internet video, Callahan (2103) states that, “We all have......

Words: 339 - Pages: 2

Critical Thinking

...Critical Thinking University of Phoenix MGT/350 Jessica Collins February 19, 2010 Abstract Critical thinking is the process in which managers, supervisors and leaders use to make rational decisions while minimizing a certain amount of risk. When given a task to accomplish, good leaders use their own skills while recognizing and utilizing other people’s skills helping one another to achieve the best outcome for their goal. Being able to recognize their own individual strengths and weaknesses, seeking out council from senior leaders or peers and “thinking outside the box” are valuable assets to have when applying critical thinking. Applying Individual Critical Thinking Implementing critical thinking skills plays a vital role into not just how decisions are made, but also how some people may perceive that individual’s role within an organization. A good leader is perceived as someone who not only has good skills in performing duties such as making on the spot decisions, but they are also viewed as having self-confidence in everything they do. For example, I have been under supervision of many leaders, some of whom I remember because of their leadership styles more than them as individuals. While I remember a lot of negative styles, I have taken the downsides of how we were treated as an experience of how I wouldn’t be toward my own soldiers. I have had a few leaders who would act like the big boss around us but shrink when someone of higher-rank question......

Words: 931 - Pages: 4

Critical Thinking

...Critical thinking and Ethics Andrea Parham Gen/201 02/09/15 Lisa Moellering Critical thinking and ethics are important things to use while decision making, defining critical thinking, knowing the process of critical thinking, and knowing how you’re preferred ethical lens all play a part in how you make decisions. Defining Critical Thinking What is critical thinking? Critical thinking is self-disciplined, self-monitored, and self-corrective thinking that is clear, rational, open-minded, and informed by evidence. Critical thinking is also the mental process of actively and skillfully conceptualizing, applying, analyzing, synthesizing, and evaluating information to reach an answer or conclusion while sustaining judgment. The Critical Thinking Process The steps in the critical thinking process are as following: Remembering, understanding, applying, analyzing, evaluating, and creating. These six levels of thinking actual build on each other. Remembering is the first level this action calls for recalling information heard or read. The next step is understanding, once you have remembered what you have read or heard, or seen now you have to make sure you understand it. A great way to master this step is by relating what you already know. Get personal with the information obtained as the more you relate it to things you know the more you will comprehend what you remembered. The third step is applying, this step allows you to put task to practical use so you are applying......

Words: 745 - Pages: 3

Critical Thinking

...Critical Thinking Alex Mowry Everyday decisions are made consciously and subconsciously by people. The decisions could be subtle, or big life changing ones. Making a clear reasoned judgment is critical thinking and should be used for you decisions made (Beyer, 1985). Critical thinking isn’t as simple of a process as it sounds. There is a six step process that can be used for critical thinking to make a more efficient decision. Many things can affect the critical thinking process such as emotions and being influenced by others. Mastering the critical thinking process is needed and suggested. Critical thinking is used every day and could be applied to more than one area of a person’s life. There is a 6 step critical thinking process that was made by Benjamin Bloom that can be used to clearly evaluate your thinking. The six steps used are remembering, understanding, applying, analyzing, evaluating, and creating. Level one is remembering. Remembering is being able to recall and recognize key points. This will allow you to go back and start the process by recalling it. Level two is understanding. Understanding is being able to explain what you are remembering. Level three is applying. Applying is being able to complete a task from the knowledge you have obtained from the previous steps. Level four is analyzing. Analyzing is taking a step further from understanding by expanding what you know and breaking it down into parts. Level five is evaluating. Evaluating......

Words: 560 - Pages: 3

Critical Thinking

...Critical Thinking Application What is the definition of Critical Thinking? What are some examples from my personal experience in applying critical thinking to a work-related decision, and the importance and benefits of critical thinking in the decision-making processes? If want the answers to these questions, keep reading this paper and you will have all the answers. Critical thinking is reasonable reflective thinking focused on deciding what to believe or do. Under this view, critical thinking is relevant not only to the formation and checking of beliefs, but also to deciding upon and evaluating actions. It involves creative activities such as: • formulating hypotheses’, plans, and counter examples • planning experiments; • seeing alternatives Ennis, R. H. (12/31/2010) Critical thinking is very important. Critical thinking gives people the way to react to matters by figuring out what is true or false and a persons feeling or opinions, to draw warranted conclusion and generalizations. Critical thinking also adds the skill to think of questions, build, and make out the structure of arguments, and effectively back up arguments. A person must be able to define, analyze, and develop solutions for problems and different types of issues. When someone evaluate information, data, and materials by coming up with inferences, making a logical and educated conclusions, applying one’s perception and facts for different and latest problems, making a sane and logical......

Words: 405 - Pages: 2

Critical Thinking

...Critical Thinking Evangelina Villela GEN200 February 11, 2015 Critical Thinking Critical Thinking is a learned skill developed by broadening your viewpoints through clear thinking. It is the process of evaluating issues to form rational, open-minded conclusions to solve problems better. A psychologist named Benjamin Bloom named six levels of thinking. He called them a taxonomy of educational objectives (Ellis & Toft, 2015). The six levels are Remembering, Understanding, Applying, Analyzing, Evaluating, and Creating are the six levels in the critical thinking process. Emotions from the loss of my daughter have affected me and my decision-making process. As a professional in the United States Army, I had to evaluate this life changing event to determine whether to continue my tenure or retire. I could no longer accept the responsibility of teaching, coaching, and mentoring young Soldiers to become future leaders and better citizens of society. Remembering is the process of recognizing or recalling key terms, facts, or events that you have experienced in the past. This step can be used to grasp an understanding and identifying the central issue of what is being communicated. Upon finding the topic, determining the point is the next step. The issue is the question in which the author asks and answers. Applying this step can help you draw factual information to reach an answer or conclusion in evaluating your ideas, and obtain the knowledge of what is communicated.......

Words: 709 - Pages: 3

Critical Thinking

...Critical thinking and Ethics GEN/201 September 1, 2015 Critical thinking and Ethics Critical thinking and ethics have a larger role in different cultures. Many people can often be seen being involved in activities associated with Critical thinking and ethics. This is partly because people of most ages can be involved, and families are involved in by this. A person who displays their dislike for Critical thinking, and ethics is perceived as an outcast.  Critical thinking is a disciplined process of actively processing, applying and analyzing information that was gathered or generated by a conversation or article. We have the ability to think with clarity and accuracy to determine new concepts or solutions.   There are six steps for critical thinking. There are as follows:   1. Remembering- processes that the individual can recall important facts of the information that was read.  2. Understanding- the ability to comprehend the text and understand what is under discussion. 3. Applying- applies the information on your thoughts.  4. Analyzing- analyzes all the aspects of the information given.  5. Evaluating- evaluate the findings of the information.  6. Creating- creates innovative solutions or conclusions.  The use of critical thinking of your everyday life situation can be proactive because you can analyze more a situation and make better decisions. Understanding what, why and how of a situation will give you more clarity in decision......

Words: 620 - Pages: 3

Critical Thinking

...Critical Thinking Critical Thinking The concept of critical thinking explains a process that involves utilising various interrelated skills to integrate, analyse and carefully evaluate what peoples read and hear from some sources. Therefore, critical thinking requires a determination of whether we should accept, reject or suspend judgement regarding a claim to acting in a certain way (Massey, 2015).This essay analyses steps to critical thinking, how emotions affect decisions making and critical thinking in professional and societal responsibilities. Critical thinking include knowledge, comprehension, application, synthesis and evaluation. In critical thinking, knowledge includes the most fundamental level of information. In this step, the individual identifies what the source of the knowledge says, the topic and issue. The next step is comprehension. The step involves having a comprehensive understanding of the idea. A critical thinker should, have an understanding of what is seen and read. The understanding gained by the critical thinkers is important in order to obtain new knowledge by reflecting on what is known. The ability of the individual to form own interpretation and to express it through writing to give it a new significance measures the level of individuals understanding. The application requires the person to know what they have read, heard from the source. Further individuals should have knowledge of how to apply the same......

Words: 545 - Pages: 3

Critical Thinking

...The dictionary defines critical thinking as a “disciplined thinking that is clear, rational, open-minded, and informed by evidence.”  So, we must ask ourselves how we obtain critical thinking.  Are there steps that one must take?  Is there only one-way to reach critical thinking?  Is this something that can be taught to another person or explained?  Do ethics and critical thinking ever intertwine?  With so many questions revolving around this subject, I am going to use the rest of this paper to delve into the hard questions.  We are going to explore the steps of the critical thinking process in detail while applying those steps to my personal blind spot and preference in the ethical lens spectrum and we will discuss the effects of ethics in comparison to professional and societal environments. There are six basic steps to the critical thinking process.  Our text, Becoming a Master Student, relies on psychologist Benjamin Bloom to explain the steps.  1)  Remembering  2)  Understanding  3)  Applying  4)  Analyzing  5)  Evaluating  6)  Creating.  (Ellis, 1976, p. 205).   As we start to form the initial research behind the idea or paper these steps become very important in narrowing the field of vision and applying these thoughts to real life.  We need to remember what we are reading or researching.  I personally struggle with remembering some of the small details.  I can get lost in the big picture of the project.  We then need to understand what we are reading; the best way......

Words: 821 - Pages: 4

Critical Thinking

...Critical Thinking Carla Davis-Mann GEN/201 November 16, 2015 Dr. Towanda Martin Critical Thinking Critical thinking is defined as the process of actively and skillfully conceptualizing, applying, analyzing, and evaluating information gathered from or generated by observation, experience, reflection, reasoning, or communication as a guide to belief and action. (telicthoughts). Critical thinking, to me, is the process of thinking that is used for different types of judgments. Critical chinking is also used for decision making and problem solving. Critical thinking allows us to apply or thoughts and digest them carefully for the decisions that have to be made ethically. It is always best to make the correct choices when you have no distractions, and critical thinking does not allow for distractions. That, of course, does not mean that our thought process will always be correct. Critical thinking frees us from nonsense. (Ellis, 2015) p.215. There are six steps in the critical thinking process. They are remembering, understanding, applying, analyzing, evaluating, and creating. Every level is useful and needed. The lower levels, remembering, understanding, and applying, are only looking for a quick answer. The higher levels, analyzing, evaluating, and creating, has several options that can be used for answers or you can create your own. Using all these levels of critical thinking, is the beginning of becoming a master student. When solving problems, critical......

Words: 645 - Pages: 3

Critical Thinking

...Critical Thinking and Decision Making Inessa Arutunyan Linda Iacoboni Anisha Lalwani Dan Sarbu MGT/350 November 7, 2011 James Chatterton Critical Thinking and Decision Making Critical thinking is thinking comprised with careful judgment. One gathers facts and evidence then analyzes the data to come to an objective conclusion. Decision-making is the process of arriving at an agreement through careful analysis without bias. When applying the process of critical thinking sound and solid decisions evolve. Several types of thinking can enhance or inhibit critical thinking when one is moving toward a decision. For example, emotional thinking or, sometimes referred to as emotional intelligence. Emotions are "a state of consciousness having to do with the arousal of feelings” (Webster’s New World Dictionary). Feelings can be pleasant or unpleasant that one can react to when in action or thinking. Intelligence is a measure of the amount a person can favorably (or unfavorably) apply sound judgment and reason to a situation while deciding their feelings to the situation (Elder, 1996). Critical thinking is the ability to advance ones thinking toward logic and the capacity to analytically reason. Emotions can cause a defect in critical thinking. Emotions are one’s internal gauge, letting one know how he or she is doing in......

Words: 1483 - Pages: 6

Critical Thinking

...Critical Thinking and Ethics: Critical thinking and ethics are such an important topic in today's business world. With an idea that is always developing it is important to understand what these mean, and how these work. Let us look at critical thinking first. Critical thinking's definition is: being able to apply knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis, and evaluation in everyday problems (Athanassiou). Knowledge is to recall what is previously learned, comprehension shows awareness of material, the application uses data to answer questions, analysis breaks down material, synthesis recombines information from the analysis, and evaluation displays one's judgment of the value of information received (Athanassiou). This process should apply to many everyday situations. When you are dealing with children, it can be a very busy situation. It is best to know each child you deal with; everyone has different emotions. You can use the knowledge and understand how to treat a child in a manner that helps the child behave in the best manner possible for you. By doing this, you would ask; how do I get my child to behave in a good manner? At this point, you recall that they acted well after using energy at the park, so you proceed to the park. Next you would give simple instructions to see how well they can listen; if they can follow simple instructions its a success. Next, you would understand that if your child arrives at the park this would allow them to burn......

Words: 672 - Pages: 3

Applying Critical Thinking

...Applying Critical Thinking Critical thinking is an important way of thinking in a business setting. This type of thinking involves decision-making and thinking of all elements of a specific decision. When all of the elements of the decision are explored, and different alternatives are presented, the individual or group involved in the decision the best possible alternative is chosen (Natale & Ricci, 2006). The health insurance field uses critical thinking in all aspects of business decisions. Critical thinking includes understanding the concept of using critical thought and knowing the direction that thought is going to take the group or individual (Natale & Ricci, 2006). Thinking happens every second of every day, the best type of thinkers are the thinkers who think about what an individual is thinking (Paul & Elder, 2006). These thinkers think about what their thinking and may ponder on what one is thinking and then these thinkers act upon that thought (Paul & Elder, 2006). The best thinkers use critical thought in the workplace and create many solutions to different issues or problems within an organization. In organizations, it is important for an organization to develop employee’s critical thinking skills. Employees who think about what the individual is thinking and come up with the best alternative solutions can hold a competitive advantage over competitors (mindtools.com, 2010). Blue Shield of California (BSC) is a leading health insurance company in the state of......

Words: 735 - Pages: 3