An Exploratory Study Into Failure in Successful Organizations: the Case of Marks & Spencer

In: Business and Management

Submitted By jasperzhou
Words 462
Pages 2
Paper Title:
An Exploratory Study into Failure in Successful Organizations: The case of Marks & Spencer

Author: K. Mellahi, P. Jackson and L. Sparks

Journal : British Journal of Management, vol 13, 15-29 (2002)

Web access:
This journal can be accessed through the Polyu library: Question: 1. Discuss the reasons of failure for M & S.

1 Top managers tended to underestimate the effect of external changes in the industry landscape and, at times, disbelieve external reports and studies.

2 M&S lost contact with its customers’ needs and wants.

3 Powerful managers focus on their own benefits in a large part, ignoring give some solutions to the development of company.

4 Some conceptions of management and old policy have become a block to develop in an entirely new circumstance. At the same time the leaders always avoid to answer some underlying problems and find some excuses.

5 a. Rather than continuously looking for new ways of managing the company under changing circumstances, it continued to preserve and do what was previously successful. Be

cause of its long and continuous success.

b. M&S not only stuck to its previous routine procedures, but when change was under- taken, the company initially exhibited modification routines by using similar change and modifica-tions made to the management and operation systems throughout the company’s history.

6 Internally there were ‘political’ rumblings within the company, particularly over the lack of relationship between the Chairman and his Deputy, and issues of succession.

Every emperor has a cabinet composed of his own favorites.


External environment changes: consumer’s desires and behaviours…...

Similar Documents

Mark and Spencer Case Study

...A case study on Marks and Spencer which includes: The company at present, Background of the Study, Case Background, Problem, SWOT Analysis, Alternative Courses of Action, Recommendation, Conclusion. A Case Study on Marks and Spencer The Company at Present Marks and Spencer has over 450 stores located throughout the UK, this includes the largest store at Marble Arch, London. In addition, the Company has 150 stores worldwide, including over 130 franchise businesses, operating in 30 countries. Background of the Company * Marks and Spencer (M&S) of Britain (often referred to as Marks & Sparks by locals) is a general retailer that sells clothes, gifts, home furnishings, and foods under the St. Michael trademark in the UK, Europe, the Americas and Far East. * The company also operates financial services segment, which accounted for about 3% of the company’s 1998 profits (Dow Jones Industrial 1999) * Marks & Spencer started as a stall in 1884 by Michael Marks in the Leads market using an L5 loan from a wholesaler * Its philosophy is to sell durable merchandise at a moderate price. It has merchandise made to its specifications. * By 1901, the company acquired 35 Outlets as well as a new partner, Tom Spencer * By 1949 all the company’s stores carried mostly private label (St. Michael) products produced by British suppliers (De Nardi-Cole 1998). Case Background * Britain has often been called a country of shopkeepers, and Marks &......

Words: 4103 - Pages: 17

Marks & Spencer

...Marks & Spencer Marks & Spencer was founded on 1884 as a market stall by Marks. It became Marks & Spencer in 1894 as a partnership with Spencer. From that humble beginning Marks & Spencer became leader in the industry. And for more than half a century M & Spencer was the epitome of enlightened capitalism. It dominated the British high streets and provided shoppers with quality and value clothing unrivalled by competitors. It was one of Britain’s largest high profile retailers selling variety of goods and services such as clothes, food, furniture and loan services. But its glory has started to crumble when it profits began to fall since 1998. M & S has been facing their worst times ever. Their problems began at the start of financial year April 1999. They suffered almost from financial ruins. Since the event of its failure, M & S has been taking more than several attempts to recover their losses. Extensive studies and researches have been conducted to find out the root causes so as to come up with appropriate strategies for development. Most of the studies started with the company’s profile. Below is an analysis of the company’s profile and the validity of one strategic management models to Marks & Spencer’ experiences. Marks & Spencer’s organization culture is characterized as a reflection of “taken for granted fashion” that is an attitude shared by members of the organization. The beliefs and basic assumptions operate unconsciously among the members and also exist at the......

Words: 1579 - Pages: 7

Marks & Spencer

...Instructor’s Manual CASE TEACHING NOTES Marks & Spencer Nardine Collier and Gerry Johnson 1. Introduction This case study is about why one of the world’s most famous retails, Marks & Spencer, ran into trouble at the end of the 1990s and how it attempted to manage a programme of change to overcome those problems. It is therefore useful to explore issues concerned with organisational culture, strategic drift, strategic choice and the management of change. The case covers both the history of Marks & Spencer throughout the last century and, in more detail, from 1998 to 2004, the period when it moved from a position of market dominance to one in which it was deemed to be a take-over target. The case charts the attempts by its different chief executives to address the problems during this time and, therefore, the various change initiatives that were mounted. 2. Position of the case The case study relates, in particular, to the problems and means of managing strategic change in Marks & Spencer. So it is particularly related to the coverage of strategic inertia and strategic drift in chapter 1 and programmatic design and change in chapter 10. With this in mind it might be taught at the end of the strategy course. However, it could also be used as a case to require students to analyse the reasons for the problems of Marks & Spencer, not only in terms of organisational culture, but also in terms of the market and competitive position of the firm. In this sense it could......

Words: 4533 - Pages: 19

Marks and Spencer

...An Analysis of Marks and Spencer INTRODUCTION TO THE FIRM AND ITS INDUSTRY Marks and Spencer is one of the largest retailers in the United Kingdom, and is also known as a major retailer selling diverse product ranges under their own exclusive brand in more than thirty countries. Customer confidence in the Marks and Spencer brand remains second to none. According to recent research undertaken by the Company, it shows that, in clothing, Mark and Spencer has a clear lead over all its major competitors in the key areas of fit, quality, trust, breadth of range and customer service. In November of 2000, Marks and Spencer will launch a trial of three new lingerie-only outlets in Paris, Hamburg and Dusseldorf. According to industry statistics, Marks & Spencer remains the clear leader in the UK lingerie market, with over thirty percent of the market share. These pilot stores, distinctly branded 'msl', are designed to showcase the product range, taking the very best of Marks & Spencer lingerie to the Continent. Moreover, twenty-five percent of the 'msl' range has been designed exclusively for the continental market (Marks & Spencer PG). According to David Norgrove, Marks & Spencer Executive Director, the new stores developed by Marks and Spencer "clearly show how we can give customers what they want in the way they want it. Today we have both depth of product and a variety of retail formats, so that we can encompass factory outlet stores and designer clothing......

Words: 1617 - Pages: 7

Dick Spencer Case Study

...* Dick Spencer Case Study Introduction  In this report, I mention about a case study to highlight the managerial issues faced by an organization. Spencer was a plant manager of Modrow Company, a Canadian branch of Tri-American Company. Dick did his MBA and served this company for 14 years. He started his career as a salesman. With time he continued to work successfully on different contracts and finally he was spoken of as “boy of watch”. Later he wanted to move on different career domain, so he finally transferred to the home office of organization. He was nominated as an assistant to senior vice president of production. In the following sections, we will cover the managerial issues faced by dick and his organization. We also try to provide some recommendations about managerial issues identified, researched and evaluated. Managerial Issues We identified the following managerial issues. Micromanagement According to the Wikipedia, micromanagement is a management style whereby a manager closely observes or controls the work of subordinates or employees. Micromanagement generally has a negative connotation. (Wikipedia) Rather than giving general instructions on smaller tasks and then devoting time to supervising larger concerns, the micromanager monitors and assesses every step of a business process and avoids delegation of decisions. (Wikipedia) According to the journal, “Micromanagers read your proposals, tell you to develop your prototype, and then insist on telling......

Words: 3546 - Pages: 15

Marks & Spencer

...Marks and Spencer: Plan A Issue: Issue of the Marks and Spencer written below: * Fluctuation in M&S sales (According to data which provide in the case show that M&S growth is not constant) * High prices then competitor like Tesco Value (Cost of M&S is high while competitor prepare the product at low cost) * In UK company face perfect competition * Social environment (In the past M&S face problem in social image but still they implement “Plan A” in future) * Plan A is perfect and in future it is successful? Analysis: Fluctuation in M&S sales: Sales of M&S do not grow at constant rate. Sales growth rate varies from year to year in some year growth is high and in some year growth is low and in some year growth is negative. For example in 2004 growth as compared to 2003 at 27.04% while in 2005 growth is 9.09% in next year 2006 growth is negative -17.34% and next year 2007 is 42.85%. High prices then competitor like Tesco and Sainsbury’s: Cost of M&S is higher than competitor because M&S use 100% British made products. So that the competitor took advantages of this by offer high quality and low cost imports to undercut M&S’s prices. In UK M&S face perfect competition: Because the market of the UK full saturated and all companies face perfect competition. Due to this reason growth rate in the UK market is not good or attractive. For further expansion M&S move toward other Market in different......

Words: 762 - Pages: 4

Case Study - Marks & Spencer

...MARKS & SPENCER | | | | | | | | TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 3 INTRODUCTION 4 OBSERVATORY RESEARCH AT M&S 6  THE PROCESS DESIGN AT MARKS & SPENCER 6 PROCESS MAPPING 6 THROUGHPUT EFFICIENCY 10  THE LAYOUT OF THE STORE 12 ISSUE ARISING FROM CUSTOMERS’ SURVEY: THE STORE LAYOUT 12 M&S STORE LAYOUT IN BRIGHTON – A FUNCTIONAL LAYOUT 13 DISTANCE TRAVELLED IN M&S BRIGHTON 15 WHAT IF THE LAYOUT WAS CHANGED? 18 RECOMMENDATION 20 IMPLENMENTATION PLAN 21 BIBLIOGRAPHY 23 APPENDIX 1: 25 APPENDIX 2: 26 APPENDIX 3: 35 APPENDIX 4: 38 APPENDIX 5: 40 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This report examines the daily Operations Management at Marks and Spencer (M&S) Brighton. Due to the poor performance of the clothing side, the company’s revenue has decreased by 6.8% in the past three years while the other retailers have been enjoying increasing profitability levels (WEARDEN, G, 2013). In order to analyse the reason behind deteriorating sales, the report would use a number of Operation Management techniques and practical observation to investigate one of M&S’s stores located in Brighton with regard to its daily operations and store layout. While also suggesting recommendations and an implementation plan that could help M&S improve its performance and efficiency of its in-store operations. INTRODUCTION Mark and Spencer (M&S) is one of the UK’s leading retailers with over 731 stores across...

Words: 7140 - Pages: 29

Marks and Spencer Case Study of Plan a

...Marks and Spencer: Summary Report of the Case Study Introduction Marks and Spencer (M&S) is a leading UK retailer selling clothing, food, and housewares. In 2007, the company put sustainability at the heart of its business. In order to succeed, it would have to change the attitudes and the behavior of its shoppers. As a result, it launched Plan A which set out a five year plan involving 100 social and environmental commitments that were expected to shape the future of the company. Plan A would allow the company to resolve some of the big issues facing their business. They called it Plan A because there is “no B when it comes to conserving the earth’s finite resources” (Marks & Spencer Website). Brief Background on Company In 1884, Michael Marks started the company by selling an assortment of goods in an open-air stall in Leeds, UK. In the 1920’s, the company went public and expanded into general merchandise and ready-to-wear clothing. By the 1970’s, the company had become a British icon and a household name. However, from the 1980’s to 1993 came the troubled years. Despite the expansion of its operations in the 1980’s, the retailer had failed to keep current with its shopper’s preferences and this led to financial woes. From 1994 to 2006, it was back to the basics for the company. By 1996, it had rebounded to become the UK’s most profitable retailer. However, this recovery was short lived, and M&S experienced a significant slump in business in 1999 which continued into......

Words: 1155 - Pages: 5

Case Solution of Mark and Spencer

...Part 01 Executive Summary M&S as an organization has faced a number of challenges in its 130 year existence, but has successfully weathered each challenge as it presents itself with relative aplomb. The foundation upon which the whole business has rested since its inception in 1884 was in its initial form, involved selling carefully chosen, good quality goods with low margins, and achieving volume sales (relatively speaking, at least) through Michael Marks' Penny Bazaars in the North West of England. This strategy was overwhelmingly successful, and continued to be the central tenet of M&S strategy for many years. M&S sailed through the depression and several recessions, but at the end of the 1990's something went severely wrong. Profits were falling year on year and the footfall in the stores was lower than it had been for several years. From the year of 1991 to 1998 it started to regain its profit again. But from 1999 the situation started to worsen again. This report sets out many of the reasons for that failure then concludes by suggesting and evaluating the strategic options open to the organization going forward. The report concludes that drawing on the substantial capital resources of M&S, brand and product development are the appropriate measures to take in order to put M&S back on the retail map. 1|Page Part 02 Strategic Profile and Case Analysis Purpose Strategic Profile The case study provided several descriptions on the basic elements of the......

Words: 3005 - Pages: 13

Dick Spencer Case Study

...philosophical for quality, personal, and organization improvement (Pryor, White, & Toombs, 2007). All these quality processes requires ‘doing the right thing the right way the first time and every time’. In 1996 Brown identified four ethical approaches used in making judgments as to what is the right thing to do. #1: What is right is determined by an absolute, widely accepted standard that is independent of the actor. #2: The intentions or motives of the actor determine what is right. #3: The effects or consequences of the actions or choices of the actor determine what is right. #4: What is right is determined by the situation. In America these four approaches were added to Total Quality Management (Pace, 2007). The Japanese quality movement after WWII got its start from Dr. Deming. Deming provided Japan with ‘Statistical Quality Control’ (SQC), worked to improve their industries as late as 1960s. Also in Japan was Dr. Juran, who helped move Japan from SQC to Total Quality Control (TQC), in the mid-60s. By 1993 Statistical process control charts were used in some factories. ISO 9000 Certifications started 1990 and by 1993 300 companies were ISO-certified (Pecht & Boulton, 1995). Japan is more pragmatic than the U.S. Strategic Quality Management is explicitly ethical and in particular is humanistic (Pace, 2007). Works Cited Pace, L. (2007). The Ethical Implications of Quality. Electronic Journal of Businss Ethics and Organizational Studies, Vol. 12, No. 2 . Pecht,......

Words: 466 - Pages: 2

Marks and Spencer Case

...Financial Statement Analysis Assignment 4 “Mark and Spencer’s Accounting Choices ” 20 February 2015 Semester 2, Period 1 2014/2015 Samantha Jay (10962670), Tutorial Group 1 Michelle Liva ()10962581, Tutorial Group 2 ___________________________________________________________________________ 1. Exhibit 1 and 2 report the income statements and excerpts from the notes to Marks and Spencer’s financial statements for the fiscal years ending between March 21, 2005 and March 31, 2009. Critically analyze M&S’s accounting choices. What choices may have helped the company to overstate its net profits between 2005 and 2009? In the report, it states that Marks and Spencer was criticized for the company’s accounting for pension liabilities, intangible assets, and depreciation. In regards to pension liabilities, Marks and Spencer reports these liabilities as equity. In 2007, M&S sold and leased back 1.1 million of its property portfolio to a joint venture with its own pension fund. M&S has full control since it was leased back from the joint venture, therefore making it equity. The result of this was reducing M&S’s pension liability. Another issue is that Marks and Spencer Group treats the software costs as an intangible asset. These costs include external direct costs of material and services and the payroll/payroll related costs for employees. Typically, the capitalization of intangible assets, particularly software development outlays, is prohibited......

Words: 806 - Pages: 4

Mark and Spencer Case Study

...Marks & Spencer is Europe’s most profitable retailer with a global brand and global recognition. Its achievement largely depends on the effective use of people. An organisation may have the latest technology and the best physical resources, but it will never thrive if it does not value its people. Its most valuable asset will always be its people and the work they do. For Marks & Spencer, this means that the people who look after customers, select and merchandise the products and run the operations, must aspire to be the best qualified and equipped in retailing. This case study focuses on the challenging role of the Financial Manager behind the scenes at every Marks & Spencer store. In doing so, it highlights many of the qualities, such as leadership, adaptability and analytical consideration, required by Financial Managers every day in a busy retail environment. Working for a retailer Retailing is ‘the practice of selling goods in small quantities to the general public.’ It is a business where employees come face-to-face with customers every day. Customers can be very demanding - they enter a store and expect their needs to be met immediately, irrespective of whether the lorries delivering bakery goods are stuck in snow or that a key supplier is having production problems. Many businesses in different types of environment are able to keep their customers at arm’s length. If they need to do some training or catch up on paperwork, it is relatively easy to make......

Words: 2287 - Pages: 10

Case Study (Heart Failure)

...Case Study 1 Heart Failure M.G., a “frequent flier,” is admitted to the emergency department (ED) with a diagnosis of heart failure (HF). She was discharged from the hospital 10 days ago and comes in today stating, “I just had to come to the hospital today because I can't catch my breath and my legs are as big as tree trunks.” After further questioning, you learn she is strictly following the fluid and salt restriction ordered during her last hospital admission. She reports gaining 1 to 2 pounds every day since her discharge. 1. What error in teaching most likely occurred when M.G. was discharged 10 days ago? If M.G. is currently following her fluid and salt restriction strictly but is still exhibiting the symptoms of fluid overload in heart failure, there was most likely an error in regards to medication teaching. She would have been prescribed a diuretic to eliminate the fluid that what giving her shortness of breath, edema and weight gain but if not taken correctly or at all this would explain why M.G. is still having these manifestations. CASE STUDY PROGRESS During the admission interview, the nurse makes a list of the medications M.G. took at home. * Chart View Nursing Assessment: Medications Taken at Home Enalapril (Vasotec) 5 mg po bid Pioglitazone (Actos) 45 mg po every morning Furosemide (Lasix) 40mg/day po Potassium Chloride 20meq/day po 2. Which of these medications may have contributed to M.G.’s heart failure? Explain. ...

Words: 772 - Pages: 4

Marks and Spencer Case Study

...* With more than 120 years of heritage, Marks & Spencer is one of the best-known British retailers. The company has more than 450 stores within the UK and employs more than 65,000 people. It also operates outside the UK where it has a developing business in places as far afield as Hong Kong. In recent years, the UK's retailing industry has been characterised by intense competition. Customers are more aware of where and how they want to shop. They also know what sort of shopping experience they require. This has made it much more difficult for retailers to survive. The result was that Marks & Spencer had to develop a new business strategy. This created a period of change for the whole organisation. The period of change involved refocusing the business upon the basics. This included the three business values of Quality, Value, and Service. Marks & Spencer developed a promotional campaign that emphasised 'Your M&S'. This helped the company to connect customers with the heritage in the business. It also linked the business in the minds of customers with its two other values of Innovation and Trust. The process involved three key features: * developing products that customers wanted * investing in the environment within stores * providing good customer service to look after customers. These changes have created a business environment with more challenges for employees. Managers had to prepare employees for whatever role they would be asked to......

Words: 784 - Pages: 4


...An analysis of the results of For the year ended 2nd April 2006 Report devised and prepared by Duncan Williamson May, June and July 2006 3rd Edition Marks and Spencer Analysis Introduction This article concerns Marks and Spencer and came about following the publication of their annual financial results. There is nothing extraordinary about the results apart from two things! • • They were very big news in the business and ordinary press They have been prepared under International Financial Reporting Standards rather than under UK Financial Reporting Standards The second point took me a little by surprise for the simple reason that it didn’t seem to cause a fuss. I expected a few more explanations by accountants and analysts over the restatement of 2005’s results and the potential impact on 2005 and 2006 and beyond of the application of IFRS. Of course, M&S published comparative figures for the IFRS based results for the latest year and they restated the previous year as they should. However, I seem to be the only person who is worried or concerned or bothered in the slightest about the potential for smoke and mirrors lying behind some or all of what was revealed. Why am I worried? Well, M&S is still trying to work its way out of a fairly tough trading period and coming at the end of the transition to IFRS I wanted to hear what analysts thought about what I was worried about. This is the second edition of this article and the final......

Words: 7245 - Pages: 29